Holy Wars: Sacred geography in transition
by B S Harishankar on 02 Jun 2019 51 Comments

In 2015, at the Biennale art festival in Venice, Swiss artist Christian Büchel transformed the ancient Catholic church of Santa Maria della Misericordia into a mosque. Büchel decorated the baroque walls with Arabic writing, covered the floor with a prayer rug, and hid the crucifix behind a prayer niche indicating the direction of Mecca, the sacred city of Islam. It was much more than a provocation.  Christoph Büchel’s installation, titled “The Mosque: The First Mosque in the Historic City of Venice”, as he claimed, was intended to promote religious tolerance.

 

Vittorio Zappalorto, Venice’s acting mayor, said the Biennale organizers asked permission for an artistic exhibit, but created a mosque. The local Muslim population offered prayers in the church turned mosque. This led to huge public protests in Venice, and ultimately it was closed down by the authorities.

 

On 15 April 2019, a fire destroyed much of the 800 year old Notre Dame Cathedral in the heart of Paris. Noted writer Emil Cioran once cast a prophecy that, “the French will not wake up until Notre Dame becomes a mosque”. A Russian author has already foreseen an Islamic France. Written by Elena Chudinova, a Russian, who is a traditionalist Catholic from Moscow, the book titled, The Mosque of Notre Dame, 2048, lays out a dark future when France has become a Muslim nation and the famous cathedral has been turned into a mosque.

 

Rapid migration of Muslims into Europe is tremendously increasing, following the disastrous wars in Syria and Iraq. Simultaneously, conversion of churches into mosques and attacks in Europe has alarmingly escalated every year. In the French region of Vierzon, the Church of Saint-Eloi was turned into a mosque. The diocese of Bourges put the church on sale, and a Muslim organization offered to buy it. At Quai Malakoff, in Nantes, the old Church of Saint Christopher was converted into the mosque of Forqane. More than 800 churches were attacked in France during the year 2018 alone.

 

Muslims at Duisburg in Germany are now clamoring to turn empty churches in the city into mosques. At Hamburg, a Lutheran church was purchased by the Muslim community. Recently, the Islamic Al-Nour centre started the conversion of the Capernaum church into a mosque.

 

Islam is set to displace Christianity in Britain. The Hyatt United Church was bought by the Egyptian community to be converted to a mosque. St Peter’s Church has been converted into the Madina Mosque. The Brick Lane Mosque was built on a former Methodist church. The Fatih Camii Mosque in Amsterdam once was the Saint Ignatius Church. A synagogue in The Hague was turned into the Al Aqsa Mosque. “History teaches us that these transformations are rarely innocent”, observed Bertrand Dutheil de La Rochère, an assistant to Marine Le Pen, leader of the National Front party, in the context of ongoing conversion of churches into mosques.

 

In recent years, the pace of Muslim migration to Greece has also increased alarmingly. The head of the Orthodox Church of Greece, Ieronymos II, said in 2016  that the government’s outreach to Muslim migrants posed “a danger of Islamization” and was part of a plan to “de-Hellenize and de-Christianize” the nation. In 2017, Abbot Gregory of Dochariou Monastery of the Orthodox Church was quite apprehensive that Greece would soon become a Muslim country. Already there are unpleasant memories of conversion of Orthodox churches in Greece as mosques, such as Fethiye Mosque in Athens, during the Ottoman Period.

 

The church, which once owned one-third of the soil of Europe by the thirteenth century, as Will Durant rightly put it, is fast selling its land and buildings to a resurgent Islam which they ousted from Spain though Reconquista in the twelfth century. Polish forces also stopped the advance of Ottoman armies at the siege of Vienna (1683). Europe dominated every Muslim country in the world and violently curbed anti-colonial resistance of Muslim populations. Travel writer William Dalrymple, in, From the Holy Mountain, charges the west and its repeated humiliation of the Muslim world for the rise of Muslim fundamentalism. Now a belligerent Islam is back to settle scores with Christianity.

 

The city of Antioch in Turkey is considered the cradle of Christianity. It became a thriving centre of Mediterranean Christianity and one of the five major Apostolic Sees, the others being Constantinople, Jerusalem, Rome and Alexandria. The recent terrorist attack on the Temple of the Apostles Peter and Paul at Antioch also claimed the lives of innocent children. The bombings and destruction of ancient Coptic churches by Islamic militants at Alexandria has been on massive scale.

 

Constantinople, which bestrides Asia and Europe, and was capital of the Byzantine empire is hailed by Thomas Madden, author of Istanbul, as the greatest Christian city in the world. It was renamed Istanbul after the Ottoman conquest of the city in 1453. When Constantinople fell to the Ottoman Turks in 1453, virtually all of city’s surviving cathedrals and churches were, after being desecrated and thoroughly plundered, converted into mosques. Its renowned Hagia Sophia Byzantine cathedral was changed into a mosque.

 

Since 1935, this cathedral  is a museum, but Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has now  announced that it could be again reconverted into a mosque. Nine other former Hagia Sophia churches are either being used as mosques already, or are in the process of being renovated for this purpose. The youngest of these, in Trabzon, was converted into a mosque in 2013, according to senior Turkish journalist Uzay Bulut. President Erdogan took control of churches in the war-torn southeastern city of Diyarbakir in Turkey in 2016, and declared them state property.

 

The escalating violence against Christians and Biblical heritage sites by Islamic militants is not a post-colonial phenomenon, but has a history going back to the Crusades. It turned worse, and according to Karen Armstrong, writer and Catholic nun, in her study on Islam, Christian crusaders from western Europe attacked Jerusalem, the third holiest city in Islam after Mecca and Medina, massacred its inhabitants and established states in Palestine, Lebanon and Anatolia. Graham Fuller in his work, A World Without Islam, highlights that the first Crusade also marked the first vigorous call for Jihad against western invaders.

 

Jerusalem is now virtually bleeding due to frequent attacks by Islamic and leftist groups. The latest was in 2017 when Marxist-Leninist sponsored Popular Front for Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) and Islamic Sunni fundamentalists, Hamas, attacked Jerusalem. Noted historian Simon Sebag Montefiore in his classic, Jerusalem: The Biography, has rightly observed that the unending struggle for Jerusalem - massacres, mayhem, wars, terrorism, sieges and catastrophes - have made this place into a battlefield.

 

The Islamic State has pledged to wipe out Christian identity in the Mediterranean and Middle East. Canon Andrew White, the “Vicar of Baghdad”, says Christianity is over in Iraq. The Islamic State destroyed St Elijah’s site at Mosul, the ancient Christian monastery believed to have been constructed by Assyrian monks in the late 6th century. They also destroyed a 7th century church in Tikrit, considered one of the oldest and the most renowned in the area. Militants also demolished the Assyrian Green Church, first built in 700 AD, continuing their devastation of religious shrines in the provinces of Kirkuk, Nineveh and Salahuddin. Hundreds of Christian heritage churches have been destroyed by Islamic State, such as the Cathedral of St. Simon dating to the fourth century AD and the Mar Takla monastery in Maaloula.

 

In medieval period, Vatican marshaled campaigns to capture mosques and convert them into churches, especially in Spain. The Great Mosque of Córdoba in Spain is the second largest mosque in the world after Mecca. After King Ferdinand III of Castile captured it in 1236, the mosque was converted into a cathedral. Later, a cathedral was built at the center of the old mosque, configuring the current Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba.

 

The minaret of the Great Mosque of Seville, compared to the one at Cordoba, was turned into a church bell tower. The mosque at Jerez was converted into a church after Reconquista in 1526. Al-Dabbagin Masjid was converted into a church after the 1085 Christian conquest. The Church of Santa Maria de Tarifa was built in the 13th century over the remains of a mosque. Al-Mustimim mosque was converted into a church. Al-Dabbagin Masjid and Mezquita Bab-al-Mardum mosques in Spain were also converted into churches.

 

The ongoing capture of sacred pilgrimage sites, their destruction and conversion of churches into mosques has caused much animosity and hatred between Islam and Christianity.

 

The Christchurch mosque shootings were two consecutive terrorist attacks at Al Noor Mosque and Linwood Islamic Centre, New Zealand, on 15 March 2019, killing 50 persons. According to Professor Douglas Pratt, University of Auckland, an international expert on religious terrorism, the attacks are a form of “Christian terrorism” and white supremacy. Sri Lankan State Defence Minister Ruwan Wijewardene observed that the ghastly Sri Lanka Easter bombings on 21 April 2019 were retaliation for the Christchurch attack.

 

Southeast Asian churches in Indonesia and Malaysia have also been constantly attacked  by Islamic militants. In Southwest Asia, the 2017 Quetta church attack blasts at Roman Catholic Church and Christ Church at Youhanabad town of Lahore in 2015 and suicide bomb attack at All Saints Church in Peshawar in 2013 are few instances also claimed the life of hundreds in Pakistan.

 

In Middle Eastern countries such as Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Syria and Saudi Arabia, the situation of Christians has reached an alarming stage, close to genocide and mass exodus. An estimated 700,000 Christians have fled Syria since the start of the civil war in 2011. In areas seized by the Islamic State, Christians have been ordered to convert to Islam, pay jizya or face death. Melkite Greek Catholic Patriarch Gregorios III Laham said thousands of Christians have been killed, entire villages cleared, and dozens of churches and Christian centers damaged or destroyed. But, the secular western world is incapable of fully understanding the threat of a reawakened Islam in the Middle East, according to Iraqi Archbishop Louis Sako of Kirkuk.

 

Currently, Africa is virtually torn due to religious riots and massacres between Islam and Christianity. Religious violence plagues the Central African Republic.

 

Contemporary historian Niall Ferguson wrote about Europe’s future as “the creeping Islamization of a decadent Christendom”. One of Christendom’s most prominent atheist advocates is the Italian philosopher and politician Marcello Pera. In 2004, he delivered a series of lectures along with then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger that presented their shared view of the need to restore the fast diminishing Christian identity in Europe to counter both intellectual degeneration and Islamic fundamentalism. Patriarch Kirill of Moscow warned that Europe must not lose its Christian roots. Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban said Europe and European culture have Christian roots. Since 2012, the country’s constitution has officially recognized “the role of Christianity in preserving nationhood”.

 

Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn, also Archbishop of Vienna, earlier warned during a special celebration for the Holy Name of Mary Church festival, that Muslims wanted to eradicate Christians and conquer Europe. The Cardinal said, according to the Archdiocese of Vienna: “Will there be an Islamic conquest of Europe? Many Muslims want that and say: Europe is at its end”. In a recent interview, Cardinal Robert Sarah cautioned that Islam is a threat to the existence of Europe and if Europe disappears, Islam will invade the world and will completely change culture, anthropology and moral vision. 


User Comments Post a Comment
Clash of the Abrahamic civilisations? Let them fight it out and probably it would be the mutual destruction of both. We Hindus can just sit on the sidelines as mute spectators and watch this drama unfolding.
Dr Rama Krishnan
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
''sit on the sidelines''? They fight between themselves, but are united against us - and have been succeeding. Read Radha Rajan's ''The Shrinking Hindu Nation''.
Bharati
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
A lucid presentation of Christian-Islamic conflict by Dr Harishankar . History of these conflicts is a wake-up call to the entire world, particularly India , where religious conversion is full throttle.
We in India, have lost Kashmir in the North and malapuram in the south to Islam . Yes as one commentater said, it is very very important to read Radha Rajan's book " the shrinking Hindu nation"

True religion should give opportunity for other religions to flourish and if it doesn't,it ceases to be a religion of peace and becomes an imperialistic political ideology. Fanaticism is the hallmark of both Christianity and Islam. It results from their Holy Book which is faulty and they are unwilling to revise/review/re interpret their Scriptures,due to the false blind belief that their founders are flawless.
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
A very well written article on an important theme . The points mentioned here are worthy to read . The demographic changes occurr in some parts of the world in favour of certain religious groups need to be assessed . when it comes to India , the muslim influx from bangladesh into west bengal and assam are a burnning topic to be discussed .
PKumars
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Sobering reading but many atheists and materialists will continue to claim that relgion does not matter and that only the economy and science/technology are important. That is a very blinkered and self destructive view.
Anon
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
So, how can anyone complain about the Ram Temple in Ayodhya
Navaratna Rajaram
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Very true
Ajay
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
So there is a Medieval and contempirary history of churches turned into mosques and vice versa.This paper is excellent for Hindu organisations to counter left liberals and Islamic fundamentalists.Kudos to Harishankar ji.
Paurnami
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Such articles are highly inflammatory and breeds hatred and intolerance in modern socities.It seems Hari Shankar writes for Sangh Parivar.Shame.
K.S.Nair
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Mr.Nair .
Counter Harishankar's article with another write up.People like you who take compliments from religious fundamentalists and write for them are parasites for our society.Cut your tail and keep a secular name in modern society.
Paurnami
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
@Bharati
My comments are in relation to what is happening in Europe and other parts of the world where Muslims and Christians are killing each other, the so called the clash of the civilisation. Does it mean that Hindus should sit on their bottom and do nothing in India where Abhramic religions have joined their hands together ??? Why jump to conclusions? Obviously Hindus should only be mute spectators and should watch the fun from the sidelines when their enemies are having a go at each other WHEREVER it takes place!!! If anything, they can encourage them.
Dr Rama Krishnan
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
This K.S.Nair belongs to left liberal groups who are agents of church lobbies and Pak militants.He is a Mani Shankar Iyer breed.

Thanks Paurnami.
Rajesh Kumar
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
" Why jump to conclusions?''

The conclusion was based on exactly what you said.

'' Obviously Hindus should only be mute spectators and should watch the fun from the sidelines when their enemies are having a go at each other WHEREVER it takes place!!! If anything, they can encourage them.''

Including in India? But you didn't say that the first time.
Bharati
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
All is not lost yet. With the advent of Amit Shah as Home Minister, articles 370 and 350 will surely be abrogated. Already the relevant officials (including the Governor) have met with Shah.

In the next little while we'll know what is going on.

Malapuram and West Bengal need to be watched. In the former white flags are reportedly flown. Mamata apparently said prayers to Mecca while on her 2015 visit to UK. It is a matter of time before her government falls.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Yes, please see page 12 of the election manifesto. However, it is also a matter of timing, and IIRC there were some reports they will wait till they get an RS majority.
Bharati
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Wonderful presentation by Dr.Harishankar.It gives a new exposure on the political ideologies of these two Semitic faiths.
R.K.Sharma
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Its a data packed article giving a good perception of organised faiths like Islam and Christianity in modern world. They have no right to speak on peace, humanity and tolerance.
Raghubir Singh
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Lucid and wonderful article.Congrats Harishankar.
T.Chandrasekhar
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
Important that UCC be brought in as soon as possible. There is the question of polygamy and the resulting increase in population.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
@ K.S.Nair.
Dear sir , don't run away after receiving caustic comments from Commentators, Paurnami and Rajesh Kumar . Have some patience to read some more critical comments from my side.
Let me begin with a simple example. Just imagine you are the host and I am your guest . You invite me to your house for a dinner or a short stay of two or three days. . Instead of thanking you, I am not only ,over staying, but taking out a dagger and demanding you to get out of your own home. How would you feel and react to the situation? Will you tolerate this ? If your answer is NO ,then you have no right to tell Hindus to practice tolerance.

History reveals the fact that the Abrahamic religions Christianity and Islam were welcomed into Bharat . However, as soon as their numbers increased ,they became powerful and massacred Hindus and destroyed temples. When the forefathers of Hindus are abused and killed ,how do you expect tolerance from the current generation of Hindus?
Both Christianity and Islam were the first to sow the seeds of hatred. As the saying goes " As you sow,so shall you reap" They sowed hatred and are now reaping hatred from Hindus.What is wrong in Hindus retaliating with hatred? The scientific law of action and reaction and fruits of action cannot be avoided.

Dr B.R.Ambedkar was a bitter critic of Hinduism,but even he rejected Christianity and Islam,as alternatives and became a Buddhist. His reasons are very significant,in the context of national security. He said " if my people become Muslims they become de- nationalised . If they become Christian, British rule will be strengthened"
That open rebellion was engineered by Christian missionaries in Nagaland was accepted even by Nehru. The Nagas used American arms and shot down our plane . The pitched battles which Mizos fought against Indian army, the desecration of Sabarimala in 1950 , Nillakkal Church agitation in 1983 , troubles created at Vivekanda Rock memorial ,kanyakumari, agitation against Gadgil Report, agitation against kundamkulam nuclear power plant are all gifts of Christians.

Article 370 is a gift by Nehru to Muslims who have used it cleverly to drive away five lakhs Kashmiri Hindus, who are refugees in their own country . Do you call this tolerance? These shameful acts of Abrahamic religions and CPM violence all over the country, especially in Kerala are not shameful for you and how do you call it " shame" on the part of the author, Dr Harishankar, for laying bare the facts recorded in history?
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
A very lucid article with valid points and comprehension.Congrats to the author.
Debashish Chathopadhyaya
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
There is nothing like an intellectual tradition in Semitic cultures.Incursions, destruction and genocide are unavoidable in their history--Past and present.

Thanks for the valuable article.
V.K.Bhat
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
When Abrahamic faiths are minorities anywhere, they demand special rights and privileges.When they become majority they deny it for others.

Encroachment and capturing of other places of worship is their agenda.

Anyway thanks for this informative write up.
Sakthivel Subramaniam
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
@ Bharati!! You win, I humbly surrender to your hair spliting!
Dr Rama Krishnan
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
Pope and Vatican has apologized the loot, arson and genozide during crusades.Its like Congress uncle Sam Pitroda's comment on Sikh massacre.

"HUA TO HUA"

But Islam is not Hindutva.The vengeance has been unleashed.Church has to pay with interest.

"What you sow you reap" is Biblical proverb.
Abhijit Pandey
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
Like mass migration of Muslims into Europe,Rohingyas migration into Assam and West Bengal,poses a grave danger to the security and sovereignty of India . Already the percentage of Hindus in India has come down from 90% in 1951 to 60% by the year 2018 . India has about six or seven States where the Abrahamic minorities are in majority .
Christian Nagaland had tried unsuccessfully to claim or carve out a separate country out of India during the Nehru era. If a Naga goes to Delhi he says " I am going to India" ,as if India is a separate country from Nagaland!!! The same tactics are adopted by tamilnadu . The DMK chief MK Stalin who has won the 2019 elections in Tamil Nadu, said that he wants a separate country called dravida nad and claims that Dravidian culture is different from the Aryan/north India culture.DMK's divisive mentality is expressed through their opposition to Hindi language. Survey shows that the number of newspapers, magazines , weeklies are the largest and stands first, English papers second and Urdu third.

The three"C"s ,cross crescent and communism that has a long history of violence,all over the world ,need not teach tolerance to the Hindus , who have practiced inclusiveness for several centuries . Abrahamic religions who convert Churches to mosques have no right to claim Kashi , Mathura and Ram janma bhoomi .
Why did we demolish the babri masjid? Ask any nation wronged by history and they will give you the answer. Why did Christian Europe launch crusades and fought a bloody battle with Muslims for 400 years? Was it not to recover the holy shrines usurped by the sword of Islam? So every people have the right to right historical wrongs suffered by it, except that is,we the Hindus.Are we the Hindus a class apart?
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
@K.S.Nair
You can speak of liberalism sitting in a democratic setup.The moment Islam or communism becomes the dominant ruler liberalism will cease to exist.Communism will die Islam and all religions die under communism.Christians should put a full stop to conversion and should focus on keeping the existing Christians and churches are in tact.No need for them to work just for increasing the numbers.First keep your churches and believers stay glued.Hinduism doesn't convert or is intolerant .So please stay tuned to realties and history.Intolerance is not limitless.
P.VIJAYAGOPALAN NAIR
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
@Dr Rama Krishnan

You must be a liberal! - because this is not about winning or losing, but about offering / seeking clarity when the actual words used do not do so.
Bharati
June 03, 2019
Report Abuse
Comprehensive article and beautiful narrative.A rare blend of academics and contemporary religio politics.Thanks Vijayvaani and Dr.Harishankar.
T.K.Krishnaprasad
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
Thanks for this article.It is a sharp write up presenting the politics of hatred and intolerance inherent in the DNA of Semitic faiths.Why they are so interested in encroaching and occupying holy sites of other religions.Thanks once again to Shri.Harishankar.
Uma Chidambaram
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
@ K.S.Nair.
" It seems Harishankar writes for the Sangh parivar" , I have this to say.
The author of this wonderful article , Sri Harishankar' ,has stated historical facts collected from various sources and not from history written by Sangh parivar. The events pertain to Abrahamic religions and its rise and fall in Europe and Sangh parivar and India does not at all come into the picture.

" such articles are highly inflammatory and breeds hatred "
Once again it is pertinent to point out that the article in question , deals with Holy wars in Europe and India has not been mentioned or dragged into the European scenario . So how can it be highly inflammatory or breed hatred among Indian citizens? There is no role of Hindus, Muslims and Christians of India in that scenario.

The Hindu philosophy is inclusive as it believes in " loka samastha,sukino bhavantu" ( let the world be happy), whereas Abrahamic religions are exclusivist in outlook. Christianity and Islam tries to impose religion on each other and both impose their religion on Hindus, compelling others to believe that their way is the only right way to salvation. Hatred and religious wars spring from their false belief that " mine is the only true right way" , which is logically not tenable. A mathematical illustration would suffice. For eg the answer 625 can be arrived in three or more ways -- 25×25 , ( 20+5)sq and 30-5sq using the algebraic formula a+b and a--b whole square. This principle can be applied to religion also.
Mini Menon
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
It seems a group of Sangh Parivar people are determined on attacking me for criticizing the author.I have just said that the author Harishankar writes articles targetting Islam or Christianity.He can write reforming his own faith which is black marked.First clean your own house before attempting to clean other houses.
K.S.Nair
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
@K.S.Nair

Cleaning my own house includes cleaning it of the poisonous vermin infesting it.

And I am not 'a ''Sangh Parivar people'''.
Bharati
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
India is coming under the grip of frightening Hindu Rashtra.Democracy is threatened.Dissent and protest is ruthlessly suppressed.Such articles and its promoters like Krishnanunni, Bharti and Mini Menon should not push India into Saffron fascism.Its a request.
K.S.Nair
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
@ K.S.Nair.
You " Harishankar writes articles targeting Islam and Christianity"
What is wrong in writing articles on any subject,if it conforms to logic and facts.? Hindu born, pseudo secularist, and congress leader Sasi tharoor writes articles/books and gives speeches against hindutva. Let me quote an instance.
These are the controversial lines from tharoor's book ' the great Indian novel ( page 71) . He said " in Kerala men of the Nair community realize that their wives are free to receive them by seeing if another man's slippers aren't outside her house" . Indira Ravindran, president of the kerala mahila samaj , claimed that Tharoor deliberately tried to defame the Nair community, by putting the statement in Pandu's mouth" ( pandu of Mahabharata).
Referenced non BJP sourse-- http:// www.indiatoday.in>story>wom.).

Bishop Franco mullakkal is allegedly accused of raping a Nun .yet we are expected to consider him as the very embodiment of moral values and symbol of secularism . So,are Kerala Nair ladies , whores and pimps??? M.F.Husain is free to insult Hindu goddess Saraswati by drawing a naked picture of the goddess of learning and this should be the hallmark of secularism. Is it not so?

You call Harishankar " Shame" ,but as a Nair, yourself , you don't want to call " shame" on Sasi tharoor and Hussain . This is nonsense of your secularism ,an outdated concept that is not practiced by any country in the world,but misused to the hilt only in India and, you say" democracy is in danger, threatened,dissent and protest suppressed"

Mr Nair sir , who ruthlessly suppressed the peaceful Ayyappa devotees agitation on the Sabarimala issue, and what is the result after 24 may 2019 ? Who ruthlessly suppressed the Hindu voice " Jai Sri Ram" and created violence in West Bengal,do that Hindus could not be able to vote a democratic government , and what is the result? So democracy and secularism was not in danger in Kerala and Bengal for last many years according to you???. Kindly do your research once again.
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
Mr.K.S.Nair
Either yiu present one example of Hindu chauvinism to counter this article and substantiate your argument.Otherwise quickly wind up.Dont open the stigmatized words and phrases like fascism and terrorism.Just feel the touch of your traumatized left in Bengal and Kerala.

Pack your red luggage and quickly quit this comment scenario.
Uma Chidambaram
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
Congrats Mr.Krishnanunni ji.I think we should ignore this man who has nothing to present substantially.
Uma Chidambaram
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
@ Uma Chidambaram.
Thanks Umaji for your compliments and support . What a laudable command by you " pack your red luggage ----"
Although BJP did not get any seats in Kerala ,it is still a relief that the red brigade has packed off .

@ mini Menon.
Fantastic. You have given good food for thought , by using mathematics and algebra to explain that Realty can be viewed in many ways, which is in contrast to the Abrahamic way that says that there is only one way to God.
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
Question paper set up is for 100 marks, passing mark is 80 and Modi, Shah need to secure 80 to pass.

Jaykumar
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
@ jayakumar'.
This article is not at all related to the performance of the Modi/Shah duo. Under which constitutional law BJP should get 80% ? Please enlighten me.
The congress is in the ICU and CPM in the ventilator support although dead .
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
@Jaykumar
Tooth and nail gone Indian leftists are affected by bone cancer.Their cremation is not easy.Chinese comrades should secure 80% will of Modi Shah duo for conducting their funerary rites in India.
T.S. Ram Mohan
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
In a broad spectrum Harishankar ji has given us the ongoing bloody encounters between Islam and Christianity.Indian media and intellectuals have hidden these facts
K.K.Ravi Shankar
June 04, 2019
Report Abuse
Dear Sir/Madam,
The items discussed herein did not find mention in any newspapers, in any detail; they probably were mulling with the idea that these are matters of 'treason against high secularism'!

I convey my gratitude for these important revelations to the author.

Coming to the Reds, they are fully entrenched in this society, albeit not always in ‘red garbs’.

The Red Brigade has not been packed off in Kerala. Their alter-ego the congress party has been given a full-mandate to carry on with the same agenda of the CPM’s.

When it comes to appeasement of Abrahamic cults the congress party has no parallels in this world. This has been their raison d'être.

Even a cursory glance at their 2019 – manifesto reveals this. They very much know that the moment they give up their anti-Hindu stance and abandon this humbug, bogus and criminal concept called secularism, they will vanish from the face of Indian polity.

Mohandoss Khilafat Gandhi and Jawahar-ud-deen Nehru did everything they could in accomplishing this almost falling short of constitutionally declaring practice of Hinduism in any form criminal.

If the current leadership of the congress party gets a chance to rule the country, they will complete the task by destroying every vestige of sanAthana_dharmam as we know it today.

There is no reason to feel elated about the defeat of the CPM led by Pinarayi Vijayan in the elections to the Parliament. The CPM will automatically get destroyed, when the congress party is liquidated completely.

It may us take several decades, possibly even centuries to accomplish this even with eternal vigilance.

Subramaniam, June 5, 2019.
Subramaniam Narasimhan
June 05, 2019
Report Abuse
Dear Shri. Narasimhan ji

The Indian media which is totally eclipsed by red brigades and a section of western lobbies hardly publish any such news discussed by Sri.Harishankar. For example, the trauma of Hagia Sophia cathedral in Istanbul which is again getting converted into a mosque is published in all global medias.The huge influx of Muslims from Syria into Europe and ongoing demographic imbalance and religious riots are well known .
Paurnami
June 07, 2019
Report Abuse
True.Many points discussed by Harishankar ji have been suppressed by vicious Indian media for fear of secularism getting eroded and Abrahamic faiths exposed.


Congrats to the author.
S.Ashok Kumar
June 07, 2019
Report Abuse
Numerous facts cited by the author to show the emerging pattern of destruction of christianity in Europe and middle east deserves kudos.

It is reprehensible and unpardonable that aware and illustrious ppl in the forum can not distinguish between 'dharma' and 'religion'. While common ppl in India and p-sec politico-media combine would like to use the term interchangeably, why do ppl like Bharati, KP Unni, NS Rajaram etc, confuse the issue.

Does God need prophets to control human beings ? Does God need human beings to worship Him ? Is he/she insecure and suffers meglomania ?

Religion is politics by other name. It is an ideology designed to enslave human mind forever. God is co-opted by cunning people so that every logical question of common people and illogical action of the middlemen (prophets and clergy) can be attributed to Him. Afterall where can an inquisitive person go to ask God ?

Dharma is about righteousness and duty. It is about spirituality that flows from God. This is universal. That is why, followers of Krishna or Ram or Gandhi or Buddha or Mahavir or Vivekanand have never become terrorists. They have never tried to convert others by sword or enticement or by coercion.

Pl wise people, awaken to the danger to human race and to dharma. Pedalling pseudo secular gibbrish and equating religion with dharma is a dis-service to this great land. Its a matter of shame if somebody does.

Therefore, inaction and watching from sidelines is not the solution. Fire should be doused when it is burning the neighbour's house not when it has reached yours. So use your pens and voices to open the eyes of the enslaved billions., those enslaved by the ideologies pedalled by clergy and mullahs .Help a person break free from the shackles of abrahmic terror to 'ghar Wapasi.
Ahmed
June 09, 2019
Report Abuse
@Ahmed

Please show where I ''can not distinguish between 'dharma' and 'religion'. ''
Bharati
June 09, 2019
Report Abuse
@ Ahmed .
There is no confusion for me about the issue. As I see it , Hindu Dharma is not identical to religion . Dharma is multi dimensional and religious duties is just one dimension of dharma. To go to a temple, Church or mosque is outwardly a religious action,but this need not necessarily be a dharmic ( virtuous) act . Some visit a place of worship with unholy thoughts, like praying for punishing a neighbor next door or another community. So your contention that religion is politics in another form is partially correct and more correct regarding Abrahamic religions like Christianity and Islam. .

Thanks for saying that Krishna Bhuddha ,Mahavira , Vivekanda and Gandhi are not terrorists . However,one person whom you mentioned ,does not fit into this category or list ie ganghi . Ganghi is not a terrorist,as pointed out by you , however ,he has been accused by lakhs of Hindus, for encouraging , Muslim terrorism and the Kilafat movement , to which he gave support is an outstanding example and this fact cannot be denied .
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 10, 2019
Report Abuse
@ Ahmed .
My comments against Gandhiji, should not be construed to mean that I agree with his rival Godse's actions. Both had their own mental outlooks , limitations, political compulsions and their own share of blunders.
It is a plain fact, that the great leader, Mahatma Gandhiji's policy of Ahimsa did not bring any positive beneficial results in dealing with Muslims of India and resulted in the partition of India.

Corrections.
Spelling mistake in my previous comment on Gandhi , may please be corrected to read as Mahatma Gandhi.
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 10, 2019
Report Abuse
@Bharati, sorry it felt offensive.

The contention is that religion is pure politics with God co-opted to hoodwink gullible people.

None of the Eastern philosophies are religion. These are pure dharma. Going to the temple or gurudwara is not religious practice. It is a part of dharmic living; though not compulsory.

If somebody misunderstands going to temple as religion, then he / she is giving legitimacy to the Abrahamic politics and attendant terrorism cum enslavement. Therefore, wise and aware people need to stop using the terms inter-changingly and endeavour to change the narrative. Then only humanity can find freedom from religion and peace.
Ahmed
June 11, 2019
Report Abuse
@Ahmed

No offence taken.

FTR, I do not equate / translate ''dharma'' >< ''religion'' and I am an atheist (religion) and Hindu (dharma).
Bharati
June 11, 2019
Report Abuse