Hindu leaders need critical self-evaluation
by R K Ohri on 01 Jun 2019 10 Comments

Radha Rajan’s latest book, The Shrinking Hindu Nation, is a grim reminder of the multiple existential threats facing the Hindu civilization, both internally and externally. It is a wake-up call for Hindu leaders, especially the avowedly Hindu Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, to do more for the beleaguered Hindu samaj. 

 

The author calls for critical self-evaluation of past mistakes by Hindu leaders by drawing comparison with Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn’s critique of post-Stalin Russia. She convincingly highlights the similarities between the dismal state of the Hindu nation and low productivity quotient of its thinkers and intellectuals, with the miseries of the Russian nation as discussed by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn in, As Breathing and Consciousness Return. Solzhenitsyn’s analysis was a scathing critique of nuclear physicist Andrei Sakharov’s 1968 treatise, Reflections on Progress, Peaceful Coexistence and Intellectual Freedom. The said critique heralded the beginnings of intellectual resistance and cerebral counter-revolution in Russia.

 

Both Sakharov and Solzhenitsyn criticized the silence enforced in the Stalinist era, including the widespread censorship of Soviet thinkers and intellectuals - artists, writers, teachers, journalists and scientists. While Solzhenitsyn extolled Sakharov’s courage in exposing the intellectual void in the country lasting 50 years since the Bolshevik Revolution, he also faulted Sakharov for not speaking the whole truth and for sidestepping the path of truth.  

 

The narrative of Hindu suppression by invaders and colonisers is worse than that of Stalinist Russia. Even 71 years after independence, the Hindu nation continues to be in a moribund state. The author has brilliantly laid bare the machinations of Gandhi and his associates and acolytes to ignore Hindu concerns about the intentions of Muslim leaders to re-impose Islamic supremacy in India. Gandhi invariably favoured Muslims and ignored the Hindus. He did not do anything for cow protection in order to appease the Muslim League. Nor did he stand up for singing Bande Mataram by all Indians, including Muslims. 

 

He vociferously supported the cause of ‘Khilafat’ not realizing that the ultimate goal of Islam was to re-enslave the somnolent Hindus of India. Gandhi had no futuristic vision. His dictatorial dispensation was exposed many times, including his non-acceptance of the election of Subhas Bose as president of the Indian National Congress.

 

The horrifying vivisection of Hindu India in 1947 could have been averted if Hindu leaders like Sardar Patel and Gokhale had mustered the courage to oppose the suicidal policies of Gandhi. Unfortunately, in post-independence India, no Hindu leader showed the courage to oppose the imposition of Nehruvian ideology; they remain trapped in what the author calls the Solzhenitsyn Syndrome.  

 

The author highlights the Islamic threat to India by analyzing the strategy of bleeding India for a repeat re-conquest by exposing the Pakistani Brigadier S.K. Malik’s book, The Quranic Concept of War, which openly advocates  the use ‘terror’ for defeating the enemy (read kaffir Hindus). She draws pointed attention to the machinations of evangelists to convert and enslave the Hindu nation.  

 

Radha Rajan has been unsparing in her criticism of the Narendra Modi-led BJP regime. She lists seven failures of the present government, including failure to build the Ram temple, ban cow slaughter and not doing enough to ensure the return of Kashmiri Hindus to the valley. She suggests four important measures to reverse the ongoing and fast-paced shrinkage of the Hindu nation: construction of Ram Mandir at Ayodhya; enactment and rigorous enforcement of an anti-conversion law; enforce an anti-cow slaughter law; and reclaim Pak-occupied Kashmir.

 

An important measure she has missed is the need to delete the words “secular” and “socialist” from the Preamble of the Indian Constitution. These two words were never part of the original Constitution and were interpolated by Indira Gandhi vide the 42nd amendment in 1976, during the Emergency. In fact, during the debate in the Constituent Assembly, Prof. K.T. Shah, a left-oriented Congressman, tried to get the word ‘secular’ inserted in the Preamble. This was opposed by Dr. Ambedkar who argued that nothing should be done to bind future generations because the need for the form of government in future will depend on the circumstances prevailing at that time and the matter should be left to be decided by the will of the people. Shah’s amendment was thus rejected. But Indira Gandhi added the words “secular” and “socialist” in 1976.

   

Radha Rajan makes a case for declaring India as a Hindu Rashtra for saving Hindu civilization from extinction. I would compare this with Theodor Herzl’s Der Judenstaat (1896), calling for the creation of a Jewish homeland. The Shrinking Hindu Nation is a must read for every Hindu whose heart beats for restoration of Bharat’s ancient glory.

 

The author draws attention to the avowed goal of jihadi warriors to destroy the faith of the Hindu masses by destroying their resolve to fight tyrants - a dharmic duty enjoined in Hindu scriptures. Unfortunately, the fact that a regular jihad is being waged to decimate the Hindus of India has been kept under wraps by the mainstream political leadership and English language media. Jihadis have established a strong forward outpost in Kashmir and have created storm centres in West Bengal and Kerala, even in Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. The book further highlights the threat posed to the Hindu nation by Christian missionaries who have stepped up their activities from Punjab in the north to Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Kerala in south India.

 

A peculiar threat to the Hindu nation comes from a motley crowd of leftist Hindus wearing communal hats and masquerading as secularists. Their penchant for heaping scorn on the Hindu masses and hurling bucolic epithets on the faith of their own forefathers has multiplied in the post-independence period. Many film-makers and leading lights of Bollywood delight in making fun of the beliefs of Hindus because they feel Hindus are used to tolerating such insults because of thousand years of slavery. At the other end stand dazed Hindu intellectuals marginalized for decades by the left-oriented supremacists who craftily captured the political heights after 1947, courtesy Nehruvian politics. 

 

In today’s decadent culture of political correctness, no Hindu leader has the courage to speak the truth. Radha Rajan boldly states that Islamic jihadis and Christian evangelists are hell bent on destroying Hindu civilization. Her treatise is a clarion call for declaring India as a Hindu Rashtra to save future generations of Hindus from annihilation.

User Comments Post a Comment
Indeed there is no doubt that jihadis and evangelicals are hell bent on destroying Hindu civilisation.

But all is not lost. Right now, with the enemy at the gates, the important thing is to defend the Modi sarkar. Already the knives are out.

One step at a time. With the appointment of Amit Shah, there is the distinct policy of a resolution of the Kashmir situation. Recovering Pakistan occupied Kashmir is easier said than done.

The Uniform Civil Code is all important. Ram Mandir will come, as soon as the Viswha Parishad and others regroup after the election.

There is already an anti conversion law. It needs to be implemented.
Likewise cow slaughter.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
June 01, 2019
Report Abuse
Hindus have a chance now to address many issue but not squander the opportunity by going after minor issues and lose sight of fundamental issues. Building Ram Temple should not be left to the government. Integrating Kashmir by removing Articles 370 and 35 A is far more important than protecting the cow.
During the Khilafat Gandhi promised support for the Khilafat in exchange for cow protection. This is not widely known, but I have discussed it in my boo GANDHI, KHILAFAT AND THE NATIONAL MOVEMENT.
Navaratna Rajaram
June 01, 2019
Report Abuse
The progress card of a student OUGHT to be evaluated by the teacher IMPARTIALLY, by giving marks for the right answers and zero marks for wrong ones.This article ,has given zero marks for questions not answered,but has not given credit for giving the right answers to some of the problems in the examination paper.

Those who do armchair speculation and postulate philosophical theories, should come out of their comfort zones, work with the common Hindu, understand his practical difficulties and witness the grim reality and sacrifices made by patriotic RSS sewaks to achieve the goals of Rama Rajya, Ram janma bhoomi,Hindu Rastra etc. These cherished goals are in the minds of millions of Hindus and the RSS is working day and night,towards these goals ,in a step by step , systematic manner.

It is essential to think with a calm mind .A frustrated,hot headed person cannot achieve the goals..He/she, just blames anyone and everyone, for the innumerable problems Bharat faces.Quoting the Bhagavat Gita,a wise Yogi said " Be actively calm and calmly active" . This is how a karma yogi should conduct himself/herself to achieve the goal.
Critical self-evaluation is a requirement not only for the Hindu leaders ,but for all Hindus,in fact for all in the world. Why point out an accusing finger at Hindu leaders only? The article is therefore ,viewed as lop sided,as it highlights only what the Modi Sarkar could not do so far, without taking into account the steady progress made by the RSS/BJP during the last 50 years, despite a very extremely hostile environment.
Panikkath Krishnan Unni
June 01, 2019
Report Abuse
I respond to a commentator above who roots for a uniform civil code. I disagree. Let Hindu personal law continue, let it be debated in appropriate Hindu settings, let it grow once again in keeping with enlightened principles and let the future civil code of India at some point be based on that. But that process will take time.
Passerby
June 01, 2019
Report Abuse
@Passerby,

What precisely is your objection to the Uniform Civil Code ? Kindly elaborate.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
June 01, 2019
Report Abuse
@Vijayaji. There is no all-India law banning religious conversion. There is also no all-Infia uniform law banning view slaughter. It's a state subject. Bengal and Kerala no ban. Some states ban buffalo slaughter too. The truth as I saw myself in TN we send cows to slaughter. Also calves pregnant buffalo and of course bulls. The best law on cow slaughter is state of Jammu and Kashmir. We need a uniform all India law.
Radha Rajan
June 01, 2019
Report Abuse
By the author Sri Ohri.
" Radha Rajan has been unsparing in her criticisms of Modi led BJP regime.She lists 7failures of the present govt , including failure to build Ram janma bhoomi temple"
Does Radha Rajan and Sri Ohri believe that LK Advani ,MM Joshi , Modi, and Amit Shah and lakhs of RSS sewaks were sleeping in their Air condition rooms? I expect these Hindu intellectuals will not be so uncharitable like the congress , and if they are ,it is very dangerous portent for Hindu unity.

The leading newspapers have recorded the participation of these leaders in Ram janma bhoomi agitation, which culminated in the historic event of demolition of the so called " babri masjid" that stood on the Ram janma bhoomi land. Hundreds of Hindus sacrificed their lives. Their sacrifices have not gone in vein. By the year 2010 , the Supreme Court was forced to accept the evidence in favour of Ram bhakts . The judgement, however was skewed and not acceptable to both Hindus and Muslims.

It is not easy to control the mind, when stomach is empty .As soon as the stomach is made quiet ,it becomes easier to do meditation as the mind is controlled , by priliminary body control. This illustration should perhaps drive home the point that we first need the barest minimum facilities like food, water , clothing, shelter and toilets. No one can elavate his/her mind to higher levels unless these basic needs are fulfilled.
As a priliminary step to achieve other higher goals the BJP had started first with its development agenda to provide basic facilities. Many pro - poor schemes were implemented during the first five years of BJP rule.( 2014-2018). This practical approach was rewarded with a handsome majority of 303 seats .

Regarding rehabilitation of Kashmiri Hindus, this could not be implemented due to increased terrorism in J&K. Although terrorists are being gunned down from time to time, the atmosphere still remains unconducive due to lakhs of Muslim who are sympathetic to terrorists.
Options are limited. 1. Mass scale genocide 2. Surgical strike within the Indian Territory 3. A better strategy would be to educate the Muslim and create divisiveness among them to weaken their movement. The third option seems to be the best, although it may take more time.
Manoharan
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
I haven't read Radhaji's book yet;but I hope to do so soon.

She is right in berating Modi 1 for its failure to keep the promises to the Hindu community and for falling short of our expectations. Modi 2 must do more for our community but must also honour the sabka vishwas promise to the citizens of India.

It can do a few things in the first year itself.
1. Appropriate changes in the relevant articles to remove Hindu places of worship from govt. control. In Kerala ( and other South Indian states) the govt. is trying to take over many temples with high revenue, eg. Parthasarathy temple,Guruvayur.

2. Amend article 21A, RTE, to either exempt all unaided institutions or include all institutions without exception under the act. RTE should be applicable to JK&L also. Items 1 and 2 discriminate against the majority community.

3. Delete the term ' propagate' from the article relating to religious freedom ( 25 -1 --profess,practice and propagate). This word is what gives the Abrahamic religions the license to convert from other religions. Rampant conversion is a major cause of disturbing communal harmony.

More complex and complicated issues like the Ram Mandir, article 370, uniform civil code, and return of Kashmiri Hindus to the valley can be taken up in the second and third years.

An urgent matter for serious consideration is birth control. The suggestion of a politician recently that voting right should be denied is an idea worth discussing with the change that the denial should be to the parents and not the children. Other penalties must also be added.It is absolutely essential to restrict the uncontrolled growth of minorities. Dr. Harishankar's article ( read in Vvani) a grim reminder of what can happen if the govt. does not urgently address this issue..
Govindan
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
@ Shri Govindan,

While I agree with your concern about the discrimination against Hindu institutions it is important to implement the Uniform Civil Code as soon as possible.

There is the question of polygamy and the result impact on population.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse
It is true that Hinduism must have upper hand in all spheres in India.For about 65 years half muslims and christians have been ruling independent India.They have permeated all strata.All these can be democratically and permanently undone only step by step.
P.VIJAYAGOPALAN NAIR
June 02, 2019
Report Abuse