Decline of anti-Modi protests
by Naagesh Padmanaban on 07 Jul 2017 8 Comments

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi continues to make waves in world capitals with his charm offensive. In his recent and historic visit to Israel, the first by an Indian Prime Minister, he was given an unprecedented welcome. Israel officially designated him a world leader and accorded appropriate diplomatic protocol. He has been treated at par with the President of the United States and the Catholic Pope. This is a great honour for India and to Prime Minister Modi. All these indicate the slow but sure rise of Modi on the world scene.

 

The rise of India in the eyes of the world is something every Indian should be proud of. But many have not forgotten that India and Indian leaders were never considered to ever significantly impact global affairs. Prime Minister Modi, in particular, attracted much scorn and street protests during State visits. He was and continues to be hounded by established global media houses with their acerbic op-eds.

 

But the recent State visits of Narendra Modi – particularly to meet US President Donald Trump and then to Israel – have been remarkable for a different reason. Unlike his previous visits to UK or the US, this time around, there were only symbolic protests (which mostly went unnoticed) in Washington DC, and none in Israel. The almost total absence of street protests was too obvious to ignore. Even the Arab countries did not seem to mind his visit to Israel.

 

Narendra Modi’s growing popularity as a world leader is only partially responsible for the dwindling protests. The sheer numbers of people at his venues to meet him have been legendary – the Madison Square Garden event is still fresh in memory. The overwhelming support he is able to generate at every venue and the credibility it has spawned seems to have had an impact on the anti-Modi protesters. But as mentioned, that is only part of the reasons. It is worthwhile to examine some of the other key reasons that have led to a decline in the protests against Modi.

 

India is an economic power house today. Many nations, including the US and the European Union, are keen to foster trade and economic ties with India like never before. The global economic scene is at best dismal. China is leading the large economies in one of the darkest recessions the world is likely to witness. The Arab nations, with oil prices tanking to lowest levels in recent memory, are not far behind in riding the misery train to recession. In this scenario, India chugging along at 7% GDP growth rate is a sure savior and the world seems to be eager to ally with India.

 

The Trump administration in the US is surely breaking away from the past and redefining international relations and is determined to create new diplomatic and trade alliances with friends and allies alike. The bedrock of the relationships is unadulterated economic and trade benefits for the US. President Trump is sincere in bringing home jobs for his people.

 

In that context, India is seen as a unique player that could help re-ignite the US economy. It is fully plausible that for its purely selfish reasons the American administration has put a tight leash on the deep state and its notorious non-governmental organisations (NGOs) that have been fronts for their agencies to create trouble for recalcitrant world leaders.

 

Pakistan based agencies that have been central to instigating and funding terror activities as well as protests against Modi have been effectively corralled. It is well known that Pakistani agencies use hawala transactions to move funds for their sinister operations against India. Like Modi’s killer media strategy, the Indian intelligence agencies and diplomatic establishment deserve full credit for quietly working behind the scenes to identify and track these activities.

 

India is reported to have developed a comprehensive financial crimes database using state-of-art computer technologies like big data – similar to the one that the US has in place. Any illegal financial / hawala transaction now runs the risk of being viewed as a potential terror funding transaction and could be shared worldwide. Even local politicians using hawala transactions will now be on their radar.

 

Demonetization in December 2016 has had a tremendous impact on hawala transactions that fueled these protests. Not only has this killed the domestic hawala industry, but also provided sophisticated tracking of these transactions originating from key financial centers like Dubai and Singapore.  Unfortunately, the Indian media, in their eagerness to shame Modi, seem to have missed the real story. Instead, they are barking up the wrong tree, trying hard to prove why the demonetization was a big disaster and economic blow to India.

 

Further, the sharing of this database with the US and other Western powers means that a hawala transaction originating in Pakistan or Dubai with recipients in India or the US may automatically invite the simultaneous scrutiny of several intelligence agencies across the world.  Data mining technologies now help agencies to locate problem zones and offending outlets in advance. This has been a big deterrent to hawala operations and the funding for protests is an important collateral damage.

 

The increasing terror strikes in Europe, specially the UK, have also in a sense been a blessing since these countries are now eager to co-operate with India.

 

In the last two years, India has successfully stitched up good diplomatic relations with Middle East and Arab nations, particularly Saudi Arabia and UAE. The new understanding provides for combating terrorism, regular sharing of intelligence and agreements to extradite prisoners and criminals who have specifically violated foreign exchange regulations. This diplomatic offensive has also brought down the funding for street protests elsewhere in the world.

 

Further, the political situation in the Middle East is fluid and the emergence of severe tensions between Saudi Arabia and Iran has forced a change in their focus. This is evidenced by lack of even symbolic protests from the Arab world to Modi’s historic visit to Israel. With years of tanking oil prices, surplus petro-dollars seem to have vanished. This has greatly impacted the nefarious activities originating from Pakistan.

 

The anti-Modi protests have been orchestrated by several forces. For now, they seem to be at a disadvantage and are hence lying low. But the acerbic op-eds and distorted reporting by global media houses and their Indian cousins will continue as business as usual. On its part, India has to be vigilant and not let its guard down. There are vital lessons to be learnt in weaving together a diplomatic canvas, aided by technology, to combat illegal terror funding. Sometimes, the collateral benefits are the drying up of street protests against an emerging world leader.    

User Comments Post a Comment
Superb analysis.
Supriya
July 07, 2017
Report Abuse
I used to read such comments from ever-so-proud Indians, a decade ago but it seems that most patriots have come to realise that, although India's massive population makes it hard to ignore, in all other respects no observers takes your nation seriously.

The vibrato voice of pride owes its genesis to US White House flattery during the initial phase of corporate colonialism, but the real world... and I am talking about people here, not politicians... has observed a dangerous exploitation of India's expanding poverty sector, and an even more naive and dangerous cosying up to Israel at the same time the rest of the world is rejecting that apartheid pseudo-nation.

Many patriotic Indians will knee-jerk reject these comments, which is fine by me, but you would be prudent to consider what I say next: The Indian economy is predicated upon emulation of China's action in flooding the world with cheap and subsidised exports produced by near-slavery labour conditions.

This has destroyed 90% of importing nation's manufacturing sector, which has led to 50% of the workforce unemployed or near unemployed, which is worse.

World sentiment has swung against this, which is partly why the UK introduced Brexit, why France nearly elected Marine le Pen, and why Americans supported Trump... and even if he did lie, the next presidential candidate will not get away with the same betrayal.

Australia has dumped Israel and will soon dump Free Trade; it now being recognised by the electoral majority that this causes massive unemployment. Only the brainwashed university graduates now believe in free trade.

But India, or most certainly Modi, appears to be oblivious to the trend. Modi is sitting on a throne made up of export promises that will most definitiely not be kept. Because they cannot be kept.

Israel will be India's only friend. Indians would be wise to check their history books and review what Mohandas Gandhi had to say about the then proposed state of Israel. Gandhi, unlike his descendants, was an intelligent realist and nobody's fool. Some might say that Gandhi was India's most glowing achievement.
Tony Ryan
July 07, 2017
Report Abuse
@Tony Ryan

Your facts regarding the Indian economy etc. are not correct, so I will not labour the point.

However, your comment about the ever so proud Indians etc. calls for some comment. Indians take their county seriously, they are not particularly worried about whether others take the country seriously.

Since you are not a Hindu, it is difficult for you to understand that Hindus take their civilisational ethos seriously. It is a long tradition and started with the Veda and continues to this day.

The word 'proud' is not quite the right word to describe that sentiment. It is an inward consciousness that outsiders would not understand.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
July 07, 2017
Report Abuse
I have had the pleasure of reading this article at least 4 times and every time i read it the pride of being an Indian swells inside me.I fully aree with the learned author. In the concluding paragraph the author could have been more emphatic about the stupidities of the so called opposition parties who only indulge in criticizing for the purpose without any objective,other than appeasement.
A very good and breezy article well written.
doraiswamyganesh
July 07, 2017
Report Abuse
A well written article covering the salient points. There is no doubt that Narendra Modi has infused a lot of organisation and method into our otherwise Chaotic system. Long may this continue.
Shanmugam Kamaraj
July 08, 2017
Report Abuse
Good article. Finally, after almost a millennium of deep sleep, there is a resurgence of Indian Civilization.

Note (@Tony Ryan): The proud Indian has stopped caring about Gandhi, and his pervert ideologies.The white man can take away Gandhi with him, now.We do not need him anymore.
Charan
July 08, 2017
Report Abuse
Thanks for the many comments.
@Tony Ryan - Good comments, but digress from the subject of the article
Naagesh
July 09, 2017
Report Abuse
Now compare NaMo with Nehru, who had blackmailed the future Father of the Nation to become the 1st PM, usurped his surname to fool the gullible citizens some of whom even now believe that Sonia Gandhi is the grand daughter of the Mahatma, foisted a neanderthal Constitution-whose salient features are law makers without any prescribed qualities, qualifications or experience, their men Fridays (popularly known as bureaucrats, who are required to help them in decision making by collecting and collating data and maintaining records) without any accountability and a judiciary which has the scope for the most whimsical decision making being held not only without accountability and beyond criticism but also protected by a totally illogical and weird armour called contempt of court- on us and all those perfidies starting with referring the kashmir problem to UN, NAM, a stupid agreement called panchsheel which the chinese blew on his face, conferred himself with the the nation's highest award Bharatratna et etc
P M Ravindran
July 10, 2017
Report Abuse