Demonetization a brahmastra against many evils
by Sandhya Jain on 29 Nov 2016 24 Comments

The demonetisation of high denomination currency notes is by far the most revolutionary feat of any Government in independent India, from which its opponents and victims are reeling even three weeks after the momentous announcement by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, on the evening of November 8.

 

The move must be assessed in the context of radical actions by his predecessors. Indira Gandhi’s nationalisation of banks and abolition of privy purses affected a miniscule elite; the poor were untouched and the middle class felt more secure with its savings in public sector banks which gave 15 per cent return on deposits, leading to the doubling of household savings in five years. The demonetisation by the Janata Party regime in 1978 impacted only the rich, who quickly managed the transition to currency notes of lesser denominations. As neither the middle class, urban poor, nor rural areas were affected, it grabbed headlines for a day or two and slipped from public memory.

 

Today, however, the poor handle high denomination notes with equanimity. The Reserve Bank of India’s preference for high denomination notes (around 85 per cent of all currency in circulation at the time of demonetisation) made these the standard currency for the middle and more affluent classes. Naturally, Modi’s bombshell announcement shook everyone.

 

It would be unfair to deny the inconvenience and suffering of many across the nation, yet it is undeniable that the majority support the Prime Minister, to the surprise of media persons who hoped to exploit their misery to embarrass the government. Perhaps the native intelligence of the Indian people has discerned more than the nation-wide Lutyens elite, spawned by the Nehruvian socio-political matrix that has long dominated the public sphere.

 

Demonetisation is the brahmastra (supreme weapon) that has killed or seriously maimed several asuric (demonic) forces tearing into the vitals of the nation. Most obvious is the black economy that has dwarfed the legal economy many times over, and frustrated development goals by denying the State its legitimate taxes.

 

Simultaneously, it has corrupted political parties, politicians, bureaucracy, police, judiciary et al, who protect this perverse system, at a price, which further distorts the system. Often, the media and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) serve as fronts for these interests; this complex matrix is now collapsing in the absence of its most powerful glue – money. This will be a complicated process as those involved will resist being drawn into the white economy (recall the poor compliance with the recent disclosure scheme). Credit Suisse Group AG, the Zurich-based financial services company, asserts that the richest one per cent of Indians own 58.4 per cent of the country’s wealth; the Government has every right to make them pay their taxes.

 

Interestingly, many small traders and shopkeepers have in the past decade moved from fully cash operations to computerizing their sales and giving receipts to customers. They, and the urban poor (vegetable and street vendors, etc.), bounced back from demonetisation within days and could offer change to customers with the new Rs 2000/- notes. That is why the social unrest desired by many aggrieved parties failed to materialise.

 

However, one must in fairness express sympathy for households with a wedding in the family; those who had difficulty in paying school fees and hospital bills, and tourists and travellers who landed in India in the immediate aftermath of demonetisation. The Government was also slow to respond to the needs of the farming community, imposing needless conditions on purchase of seeds. Fortunately, the acreage planted under the rabi crop has increased 36 per cent.

 

Cynics allege that the Prime Minister was motivated by the forthcoming elections in Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, and Goa, and has crippled his opponents who would have trouble organising rallies and undertaking election expenses. The Aam Aadmi Party’s near collapse in Punjab and forced withdrawal from the municipal elections in Mumbai supports this theory. But the rage articulated by the Trinamool Congress, with others following suit, shows that the impact is beyond States going to the polls. So far, only the Janata Dal United in Bihar and Biju Janata Dal in Odisha have publicly supported demonetisation.

 

But the real losers are the Great Crime Syndicates. Intelligence sources say the ban, smack in the middle of the wedding season, was driven by reports of a heavy infusion of fake currency to fuel terrorism. The timing preempts any precipitate action by the incoming Pakistan Chief of Army Staff. In one scoop, all fake currency stands junked as bank counting machines have scanners to detect faulty notes.

 

In Kashmir, inability to pay Rs 500/day per stone pelter has ended that menace to the police and security forces. Raids on the NGOs run by Islamist preacher Zakir Naik and allegations of a raid at the premises of separatist leader Syed Ali Shah Geelani show the Centre’s determination to crackdown on the sources of extremism and terrorism. Maoists are equally affected. Worst affected are the drug mafia, hawala agents, extortion mafias, and even human traffickers (especially of young girls). Overall, the underworld has been badly crippled.

 

There is also a large class of affluent urban professionals (one lawyer alone coughed up Rs 125 crore in cash during a raid on his premises) who have large incomes outside the tax net. Many in government service have amassed illicit fortunes. Much of this wealth, if held in cash, may go down the drain, bringing windfall profits to the Reserve Bank of India (we will know after December 30).

 

However, it appears that many have used agents to dump money in Jan Dhan accounts that are suddenly flush with money. These rich people are unlikely to personally know so many persons with Jan Dhan accounts. Only agents could deposit over Rs 64,000 crores in empty Jan Dhan accounts (over Rs 10,000 crore in UP alone) so quickly. By sealing these accounts and keeping a sharp eye on the Nepal and north-east India routes, many money laundering channels are being chocked.

 

It was a wise move to close the Cooperative Bank route to depositing trashed currency, though that is possibly the surest way to bring all black currency into the system, and the Government may take a call on this after the December 30 deadline. Certainly it must now push formal banks into rural areas, rather than leave villagers at the mercy of cooperatives controlled by political heavyweights. Demonetisation has decapitated a hydra-headed monster. It remains to be seen if it can regenerate itself, and to what extent. 

User Comments Post a Comment
Truly, demonetisation has decapitated a hydra-headed monster..
Kunal
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
Yes, you are right. Cooperative banks can spoil the game if left unchecked.
naveen
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
Great, sandhya. Only you could say so.
hari om
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
Very good article, explained the benefits in simple language.
Sanjeev Nayyar
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
This is the Modi revolution in India. There is no parallel to it any where on earth. The whole world wants to follow this experiment, but nobody got quite 56" like that.
India leads from the front, once again. This is only the beginning.
Saraswati
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
"Demonetisation has killed or maimed several asuric forces. "

Hope it BLOWS away the present incompetent Finance Ministry, the cause of the Aam Admi's sufferings since 08 November
H Balakrishnan
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
Very well articulated
Shailendra
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
A very well written and balanced article
Rakesh
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
I agree with the last point. Let's see where this ends up.

I am still unsure whether this demonetisation is good or bad.
Nina
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
Very well written Article indeed. Sandhya needs to be appreciated for this. Also, the man without whose courage and vision this decision was not possible is Our Great PM.
Prem Lulla
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
Excellent article
Ajay
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
Great read; balanced as usual !!!
KJ
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
As usual an excellent article with in-depth analysis. I wish this is made available for mass reading.
Som Chatterji
November 29, 2016
Report Abuse
I dont agree with the points made in this article.

1. And most ridiculous trump beating by BJP and their media supporters is the sudden stopping of stone pelters because of demonitisation. Either these people are living in alice's wonderland are unleashing propoganda..

Demonitisation does not make 500 & 1000 notes invalid.. rather it says these notes can be exchanged.. So the separatists in kashmir valley can still pay with 500 & 10000 rs notes to instigate riots, because the receiver can still convert in to legal cash..

The truth is that the stone pelting stopped even before demonitisation.

2. Dmonitisation is legal loot as manmohan said.. because it is the RBI which printed these money and they saying that it is no longer valid money tender means, they have destroyed their own credibility. The very concept of demonitisation is a stupid idea.

senthil
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
The current demonitisation is NOT aimed at black money, but aimed at pushing cashless economy, by artificially creating cash crunch. One of the worst kind of atrocity by BJP. Because cashless economy is a big fraud unleashed and would lead to total economic slavery by banking institutions.

I wonder why BJP and its intellectual base are longing for such doomed system. It means they dont have even basic idea of money and its history..

senthil
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
Suppose i get a loan by signing a bond. And few years after, if i say my bond is no longer valid, does it makes sense? That is what is RBI and BJP govt doing.

The currency notes are NOT the real money. They are just bond for the real money - gold and silver. It was introduced by the colonial rulers 200 years before. Till then, our society was using silver and gold coins as money for transaction.

The very meaning of rupee (rupyaha) is silver. The currency issued by RBI is a promisory note for the real silver. That's why in every currency note, it is printed as "I promise to pay the bearer a sum of *** rupees".

Those who support demonitisation, either does not understand this economic principle, or refuses to take this argument. Just blind propoganda. They justify it using arguments like govt getting so much money etc.

senthil
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
We need to understand how the entire world is enslaved by banksters and their banking systems to gauge the grave dangers of current demonitisation and the govt push for cashless economy.


Few centuries ago, in Europe, the banking system was started by Knights templar and later by few other groups . They advertised that they would keep people's money safely thus protecting it from robbers. They charged certain amount for the service they provided. And to make more people deposit money, they secretly organised robbery in the society, which scared people pushing them to these banks.

For the money (GOLD) deposited, these bankers issued a receipt note which should be shown by the people while taking back the money.

So initially these bankers are just custodians of people's money (GOLD).

People took money from these banks when they needed and used it for purchasing things in the shops. The shop owner also deposited the money collected in the same bank.

As time went, these banksters said, "The money (GOLD) you take from the bank for purchasing would any how return to us by the shoppers. Why you endure so much hardships carrying these gold. I will give you just a receipt for the amount you want to withdraw. You can show it to the shopper. He will give you goods and return that receipt to me. I will credit the money to his account. Both you and the shopper is relieved from the burden of carrying the money (GOLD)."

People were slowly made to use the deposit receipts issued by the bankers for trading. As entire society's money was in the banker's hand, they later established the receipts as currency, while keeping people's money with them permanently. People forgot the real money they deposited and started using the papers issued by these bankers.

So what is the consequences?

These bankers who originally issues receipts for the money deposited, later started printing more receipts than the actual money they had. Thus they ultimately captured and controlled the economy of the society.

When the society has started using only the paper receipts, the bankers who control its printing acquired unlimited power by their ability to print any number/amount of receipts. This would not have been possible, if the society used real money (GOLD) , as GOLD cannot be produced unlimited.

East India Company was owned by these european bankers, and rothschild is one such. Please note that it is this rothschild family, who is controlling the printing of dollars in america.


When they conquered india, our society was using Silver predominantly for transaction, while gold was used in limited way. In such system, even kings who have absolute power, do not have power to control the economy. Thus our society has the real free market economy, powered by silver and gold.

During shivaji's rule, the east india company persuaded shivaji to use their east india company money tender for transaction. But shivaji refused, because these do not meet the quality of the money issued by mughal and that he cannot enforce it which has not won the trust of the people.

Later when the east india company taken control of our country, they introduced paper currency in to the society, thus acquiring totalatarian control over our economy & society. They were able to print paper currency unlimited thus acquiring unlimited purchasing power.

Within 200 years, and after few generations, today, our people had totally forgotten the use of gold and silver by our forefathers, and started believing this colonial concept of paper currency as real money. And because of this, they do are NOT able to understand the slavery they are subjected to.

How is this historic perspective related to present demonitisation?

1. One of the reason mentioned for demonitisation is the large number of 500 and 1000 rupee notes in circulation. How did it happen? who printed such large number of currency notes? The politicians of previous UPA regime.. right.. which means a corrupt regime and corrupt politicians are able to acquire enormous wealth, just by printing money. This is the worst evil of the current paper currency.

Earlier our kings ruled their kingdom efficiently because, they could not afford to do otherwise. Their treasury is dependant only on gold and silver coins obtained through taxation. People will pay tax only if they administer it properly. Else they would leave kingdom..
The kings dont have paper currency to print unlimitedly. Gold and silver cannot be produced easily on large scale.

But in todays holy india, the government can spoil the economy and if there is any shortage of tax or want more money, they can just order more currency notes to be printed.

The previous UPA govt printed enormous paper currency to support their massive corruption.

2. Another reason for printing of large no of currencies is the rapid growth of IT sector and other export oriented sectors. These brought massive amount of dollar in to india, for which corresponding rupee notes has to be printed. As result we had abnormal no of 500 and 1000 rupees notes in circulation. All these are legitimate money.

The current demonitisation means, that RBI is just making its own currency invalid, for no reason. People who believed in the currency notes printed by RBI are made fools.

3. The BJP initially gave reason that Demonitisation is aimed to eliminating black money. but within few weeks, they revealed their original goal of implementing total cashless economy. This is the gravest danger ever unleashed in the name of national good.


Atleast paper currency is something physical we can touch and take hold of. But in cashless economy, just computer numbers displayed on the LCD screen is made as money. Like how the whole of india is fooled to believe in Electronic Voting machine, where a mere beep sign, and a number on screen is forged to become as real vote.

In Cashless economy, the government acquires much more monstrous power over the economy than the cash economy. Atleast for cash, the govt needs to setup printing press, design the notes, produce paper and ink, and then print. And there is a limit to printing no. of notes. The current capacity of printing notes is estimated to be few thousand crores per day.

IN cashless economy, the govt can create more money just by the click of mouse. It is enough to changes the total capital value in the rbi computer server.

And idiotically, most people support the current demonitisation and push for cashless, just because it is done by modi. They fail to understand that what would happen if the next election if won by congress and previous UPA regime comes back? With cashless economy in place, we are only enabling these corrupt politicians to generate virtual money within seconds, and control our economy.,



None of the Hindu intellectuals had every written these dangers. They dont have any understanding of the system. They are mere ideological writers, taking sides. There is no original thinking. there is no sense of justice they could find in the system being enforced.. they project as though anything done by modi is always right..

Modi is doing it.. ok.. everyone has to support.. modi can never go wrong.. modi can always do good for the country.. such is the crap that is being propogated..

senthil
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
+10 @Senthil,

Cashless economy disempowers the poor who are outside the banking credit card/ debit card networks. Is BJP government ready to take advantage of cashless transactions and protect Indians ? The much touted GST with transactions handled by GSTN Network is 51% owned by foreign owned ICICI, HDFC and LIC Housing. Is the BJP handing over our banking industry to foreigners ? Already Insurance business been taken over by foreigners.

There was lot of talk and election promises about bringing back money stashed abroad, mainly switzerland, where are we on that count ?

For the record, I am against black money, but the BJP government should not handover our economic activities to foreign control in the guise of fighting corruption.

C Prabhu
C Prabhu
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
It is a couragious step and great risk is taken by Modi. Let all of us Hope he will succede in this noble cause
Ram
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
Excellent article. Should be widely circulated and read. Many programs on some television channels only present a negative account of this move of demonitisation. And the hard pressed BJP spokespeople are not always able to clarify the situation to the public.

NDTV has even interviewed Naom Chomsky who has suddenly become an advocate of capitalism and called this move a breach of 'trust' ! Wonders never cease.

Judging from the bye elections and the general mood in the country the people of India have displayed their traditional intelligence as Sandhyaji has also noted.

And now the government should follow up quickly with tax reform.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
The real evils are the corrupt politicians and their crocodile tears
Seema
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
@Dr.Vijaya Rajiva ,

//Naom Chomsky who has suddenly become an advocate of capitalism and called this move a breach of 'trust' ! Wonders never cease//

Thanks for sharing this piece of interesting news.

To gain further clarity in addition to what Smt.Sandhya Jain has written please watch S.Gurumurthy's Talk on youtube. At Sastra University. It is a must watch.
J.Rajalakshmi
November 30, 2016
Report Abuse
Excellent
Naagesh
December 01, 2016
Report Abuse
@J.Rajalakshmi

Thanks for the Gurumurthy reference. I saw it on Youtube. Very important. Plan to go back and study it carefully.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
December 01, 2016
Report Abuse