Myanmar’s Anti-Muslim Policy: A Threat to the Region
by Ramtanu Maitra on 12 Nov 2012 18 Comments
Tags :
Myanmar

The inability or,  at the worst, unwillingness of uniformed and non-uniformed Myanmar authorities to put an end to the persecution of Muslims in the Arakan Hills and beyond poses a serious threat to a fragile and increasingly important economic region in Asia.

Myanmar is the gateway for the two most-populous and powerful Asian nations, China and India, to an economically-stable southeast Asia. But because of the Myanmar authorities’ historical inability to govern the northern and eastern part of the country bordering India, Bangladesh and southern China, a vast area has remained lawless, threatening to undermine the region as a whole economically. The killing of Muslims by chauvinist Buddhists, with apparent support from the Buddhist Sangha, could have fatal consequences for years to come for those who are not involved in these insane activities but merely reside in the neighborhood.

According to available media reports, on Oct. 21, a violent mob led by a group of Buddhist fanatics, killed resident Muslims and burned down their homes in Rakhine state, located in western Myanmar. A Rakhine government spokesman put the death toll at 112, but within hours state media had revised it to 67 killed, 95 wounded and nearly 3,000 houses destroyed from Oct. 21 to Oct. 25. All those killed were Arakanese Muslims, called Rohingyas. According to Iran’s Press TV, Myanmar army forces provided the Buddhists with containers of petrol to set ablaze the houses of Muslim villagers, forcing them out of their homes. This latest violence against the Muslims by Myanmar’s Buddhists has also drawn the attention of the United Nations. On Oct. 25, Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon urged the authorities in Myanmar to take action to bring an end to the lawlessness currently affecting the state, with the UN chief’s spokesperson describing the outbreak of communal violence in five townships in the state’s north as “deeply troubling.”

Earlier this year on June 4, Buddhist residents in western Burma killed at least nine Muslims as sectarian tension worsens in the region, police say. Reports say a crowd attacked a bus in Rakhine province after blaming some of the passengers for the gang rape and murder of a Buddhist woman. In another incident, at least 10 people were injured in the state capital Sittwe when police broke up a protest. The riots continued throughout the month of June.

The New York-based Human Rights Watch released satellite images of the “near total destruction” of a once-thriving coastal community that was reduced to ashes around Kyaukpyu, an industrial zone important to Chinese energy interests.

Chain in the Buddhist Fanatics

Persecution of the Arakanese Muslims by the Buddhists has been a pattern in Myanmar’s national fabric for decades. The heart of the problem lies with the Buddhist-majority government of Myanmar, which refuses to recognize the Rohingyas and has classified them as illegal migrants despite the fact that they are said to be Muslim descendants of Persian, Turkish, Bengali and Pushtun origin who migrated to Myanmar as early as in the 8th century. As a result, Myanmar’s estimated 800,000 Rohingyas have remained officially stateless, and are considered outsiders and not one of country’s 135 officially-recognized ethnic groups. Extremely disturbing is the fact that this persecution of Muslims has now gone beyond the Arakan Hills, and Muslims are now under the Buddhist gun throughout Myanmar.

The Buddhist-led anti-Muslim viciousness took this violent turn in 1978, when more than 200,000 Rohingyas were forced to flee to Bangladesh following targeted Myanmar army operations against them. The army’s aim, as Yangon explained at the time, was to scrutinize individuals living in Rakhine State and designate them as citizens or foreigners in accordance with the law and take action against those who were identified as foreigners by labeling them illegal.

At the time, a report issued by the London-based Amnesty International pointed out that the military campaign directly targeted civilians and resulted in widespread human rights abuses, including extrajudicial killings, rape, destruction of mosques and other religious persecutions. Most of those refugees were later repatriated; but in 1991, more than 250,000 Rohingyas again fled their homes to Bangladesh, citing religious persecution at the hands of the military junta and the Buddhist fanatics, who had joined the organized pogrom.

The persecution of Muslims in Myanmar has now gone beyond the vicinity of the Arakan Hills. Two incidents of grenade attacks on Muslim mosques occurred on Oct. 28 in two different townships in Karen state, which is near Thailand. A bomb exploded at Ye-Nan-Si-Gone mosque of Kawkareik and the Jameh mosque in Kyone-Doe was attacked by grenades, according to local Muslim residents.

Recent intelligence reports indicate that the Democratic Karen Buddhist Army (DKBA), a breakaway group of former Buddhist soldiers and officers of the predominantly Karen Christian-led Karen National Liberation Army (KNLA), has been involved in the destruction of mosques and forced relocation of Muslim villagers. DKBA soldiers have allegedly tried to force Muslims to worship Buddhist monks and have put up Buddhist altars. Restrictions have also been placed on Muslims to force them to become vegetarian. Both the DKBA and the State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) have forced Muslims in Karen State to do menial labor for them on a regular basis, reports claim.

Where Is Suu Kyi and her Democratic Fervor?

Also disturbing is the fact that neither the military authorities nor the civilian political groups have shown any inclination to openly oppose the marauders or come to the aid of their Muslim victims. Myanmar’s military junta has time and again sided with the anti-Muslim fanatics while maintaining its own complex political equations with the Buddhist monks intact. The behind-the-back shaking of hands between the fanatic Buddhists and the military junta on the persecution of Muslims has not gone altogether unnoticed. On the contrary, the fanatics want their backing by the military to be known.

In September, about six weeks before the latest violent attacks, hundreds of Buddhist monks marched in Yangon, calling for the deportation of Rohingya Muslims from Myanmar. Voice of America cited analysts saying the country’s Buddhist chauvinism was shaped by authorities’ attempts to form a “national identity.”  The monks were supporting a suggestion by President Thein Sein, who made a public statement saying the Muslim minority, numbering close to a million, should be segregated and deported.

It is evident that the hard-headed military junta, seeking support of the Buddhist fanatics for its own political longevity, is silently backing the persecution of Muslims. And the same could be said for Myanmar’s Nobel Peace Prize winner, Aung Sun Suu Kyi. Though she lived for decades in the international limelight as a victim at the hands of military dictators, Suu Kyi has been noticeably silent. A blue-blooded Burman like Thein Sein, she traveled out of Myanmar to accept her Nobel Peace Prize last July at a time when the Arakanese Muslims’ homes were burnt and people were killed by those whom Suu Kyi represents. (The peace credentials conferred by the prestigious Nobel Prize have already been called into question, of course, by US President Barack Obama, who is directing the unconstitutional and extrajudicial killing of individuals in foreign lands by unmanned aerial vehicles known as drones and labeling all the dead as terrorists.)

Speaking at the International Labor Organization’s (ILO) annual conference last June in Geneva at the height of the June riots, Suu Kyi said that “fear of illegal immigration” lay at the heart of the violence between ethnic Arakanese and the stateless Rohingya minority. “Of course I am concerned, and the most important lesson is the need for rule of law,” she said when asked by reporters. “We need precise laws on citizenship. I think a big problem comes from fear of illegal immigration, I think we need more responsible uncorrupted border vigilance.” She added that those deemed worthy of citizenship should get all the legal benefits that entails.

Suu Kyi has tried to make the issue part of her political campaign by saying the problem lies in the fact that the junta is not ruling the country effectively. But did she visit the victims? No, she did not. And that is because her political campaign is based on projecting a common cause between ethnic Rakhines and Burmans under a common “Buddhist Burmese” identity. And to attain this merger, ostensibly a political necessity, she has little to do with what is happening to the Rohingya Muslims. The nature of this common cause is out there in the open for all to see as the military junta, as well as senior opposition leaders from Suu Kyi’s own party—including Tin Oo, Nyan Win and Win Tin - have together ganged up against the Rohingya Muslims.

The Jihadi Threat

Naypyidaw must notice that its “business as usual” approach in dealing with its Muslim population may end up costing it a lot. Besides the UN, the 57-nation Organization of Islamic Conference (OIC) and a slew of human rights groups have spoken out against anti-Muslim activities within Myanmar. Turkey has taken a serious note of these developments. 

Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan’s wife, Emine Erdogan, and daughter Sumeyye Erdogan visited Myanmar to get accurate information about the situation. Mrs. Erdogan has expressed her horror and dismay at the anti-Muslim pogrom, calling it “unbelievable” and “shocking.” The Turkish news weekly, Journal of Turkish Weekly, said: “What’s going on in the region is just an ethnic cleansing, which has been common throughout the 20th century in Burma against Muslims. The majority of the Buddhist population of the country see themselves as a powerful nation and recognize themselves the ‘right’ to attack and chase off the Muslim residents, who were seen as ‘subordinates’ and ‘aliens’ in the country.”

Such reports will not help the Myanmar junta or the civilian democratic forces under Nobel laureate Aung Sun Suu Kyi. And greater threats are lurking around the corner. Muslims around the world, even before the “Arab Awakening,” had begun to take note of the persecution of Muslims. Some of these Muslims have turned toward armed militancy to deal with their persecutors. Their militant and violent acts have been financially supported by the oil and gas-rich Gulf Arabs, Saudi Arabia and Qatar, in particular. With the tacit approval of colonial European powers and the United States, these militants have recently turned Libya and Syria upside down and have also moved toward Islamicizing Egypt, Tunisia and Pakistan, among other nations.

This is a threat that not only extends its ominous shadow over Myanmar, but over a large area where efforts are being made by the major nations of the region to ensure peace and stability. Those efforts focus on accelerating the growth of their physical economies. To say the least, it would be naïve for the Myanmar authorities, and the political figures of that country who have sided with the Buddhist fanatics because of their own prejudices to gain domestic political mileage, to believe that the uprooted Rohingyas, driven away from their homes through the use of violence, will take it lying down and not reach out for support from militant Islamic forces elsewhere.

There are media reports that reveal a militant Rohingya group, the Rohingya Solidarity Organization (RSO), has set up a network in the Cox’s Bazaar district of southern Bangladesh. Afghan Taliban instructors were also seen in some of the RSO camps along the Bangladesh-Myanmar border, while some RSO rebels were reported to be undergoing training in the Afghan province of Khost along with Hizb-e-Islami fighters. One CNN video, reportedly secured from al-Qaeda’s archives in Afghanistan in August 2002, shows Muslim allies from “Burma” receiving training in Afghanistan.

In addition, it has been reported that following the atrocities committed in the Arakan Hills, Prince Khalid bin Sultan bin Abdul Aziz Al Saud, commander of the Saudi Arabian Military, visited Dhaka and recommended waging a military action against Burma.

In 1998, the RSO and Arakan Rohingya Islamic Front (ARIF) combined to found the Rohingya National Council (RNC). The Rohingya National Army (RNA) was also established as the RNC’s armed wing; and the Arakan Rohingya National Organization (ARNO) began to organize all the different Rohingya insurgents into one group. As Wikileaks revealed at the time, ARNO had an estimated strength of about 200 militants, of whom about 170 were equipped with a variety of arms. Ninety members of ARNO were selected to attend a guerrilla warfare course, a variety of explosives courses and heavy-weapons courses held in Libya and Afghanistan in August 2001.

In January 2012, six months before the June riots, a Bangladeshi newspaper reported a merger of different Rohingya militant groups in Bangladesh. According to the news, the RSO, Arakan Movement, Arakan People’s Freedom Party and ARNO had decided to form an alliance and work together.

These are danger signals for the Myanmar authorities to take note of. If the Myanmar leaders do not wake up to these warnings, the region could turn into another hotbed for jihadis posing threats not only to Naypyidaw/Yangon, but also to Dhaka and India’s troubled northeast.


The author is South Asian Analyst at Executive Intelligence Review

User Comments Post a Comment
The writer is mis-informed.

This conflict has much more to do with ethnicity than religion.

It is more of the conflict between Burmese and Rohingyas. Would this writer call the Tamil tiger problem in Sri Lanka a conflict between Hindus and Buddhists? or Tamil / Singhlese.

Religion is simply not a factor here, if it was why do the Bangladeshi muslims keep rejecting their Rohingya brothers who want to cross over and live as refugees?
S.P.
November 11, 2012
Report Abuse
Rakhine Buddhists have a different story to tell. They repeat the accounts spread by word of mouth or through internet sites of gruesome Muslim atrocities, and occasionally bring out blurry photographs of mutilated corpses.

But theirs is a much longer story, of chronic neglect by the central government, and of what they believe is uncontrolled Muslim population growth, which threatens to swamp them. They are frightened of the spread of extremist Islamic ideas, especially among young Rohingya men who have lived in Saudi Arabia.

Ashin Ariya Vunsa, abbott of the old Shwe Zedi monastery in Sittwe explained why, in his view, the communities could no longer live together. The Muslims take too many wives and have too many children, he said - and they abuse Buddhist women too. They don't allow women to be educated.

Those who are legal citizens, who have citizenship cards, can stay, he said - but they must become more like us, learn from our culture. As for those who are illegal - they should be confined to camps, he said.

That is in effect what has happened to tens of thousands of Muslims. The term "Rohingya" is not recognised by most Buddhists; they use the term 'Bengali Muslims', a reference to the official view that they are illegal immigrants from Bangladesh.
Anonymous
November 11, 2012
Report Abuse
Mr. Ram Taanu why do you contingently avoid this part??


How did the violence begin?

The rape and murder of a young Buddhist woman in Rakhine in May set off a chain of deadly communal clashes, which lasted for weeks and resulted in the death of about 90 people.

After the young woman's murder followed a series of reprisal attacks.


Anonymous
November 12, 2012
Report Abuse
Buddhist muslim conflicts now have become a problem in Asia . Thailand,afghanistan, burma, bangaladesh etc. The problems are fuelled by Saudi Arabia and the middle eastern countries who use their petro dollars to promote life styles that are archaic going back rather than progressing into modernity creating ghettoes of extremists.. This creates problems with other citizens who are for instance woken up early in the morning calling for prayer and opening mosques far more than it is required for the population etc. Integration with other citizens are discouraged with the enlargement of ghettoes with higher birth rates that engulf the rest of the population. It sounds that this could be a deliberate movement to destabilise asia as they did to Africa. As long as Asian governments are naive to the activities of the middle eastern countries this will evolve into a bigger problem.
jan
November 12, 2012
Report Abuse
Prosecution of muslim by Buddhist is a conflict between Burmese and Rohingyas.Rest is well known ,how the media is projecting it.
Y
November 12, 2012
Report Abuse
This article is one of the most untruthful published by vijayvaani. The so-called Rohingyas are nothing but Bangladeshi Muslims who speak a dialect close to Bangla bhasha. Like Muslims anywhere, these Bengalis are also addicted to violence and are constantly looking for ways to harass the indigeous Buddhist populaton which, unlike the Hindus of India, are refusing to take it lying down. Islam's innate intolerance is the problem, not any refusal of the Burmese Buddhists to integrate them into their society. It is utterly shameful that, instead of praising the Myanmar government for its brave stand against a violent and intolerant society, the author (who bears a Hindu name, mind well) condemns Yangon and Aung Sang Suu Kyi for not allowing the illegal Bangladeshi Muslim infiltrators to ride rough shod on the peace-loving followers of the Buddha. This is the height of intellectual perversity. Ramtanu Maitra has outdid the pinko journos of India's traitorous English language media.
PSN
November 12, 2012
Report Abuse
The people with a thinking like psn are the main reason of the mayhem that the world is going through right now.The people of his/her ilk would be responsible for "another" 1947 in India soon,just wait till modi gets elected.
observer
November 12, 2012
Report Abuse
The Mynamarese Buddhists are not like the "secular" kafirs of hindustan, used to boot-licking the blood-thirsty and promoting their destroyers. Unlike the vote-hungry politicians of india they know the basic mantra of survival. the followers of muhammad won't allow any kafir to live in peace and dignity. first let us save the endangered Hindus of india as in Kashmir, Kerala, N east/w.bengal and then think of any one else
Karam tej singh
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
It is heartening to learn that, unlike India, Buddhist countries like Myanmar know how to deal with Muslims who are a problem all over the world, not just in the Arakan region. It is shameful that the author has tried to subtly suggest that if the world does not appease the Rohingyas soon, Muslims all over the world would take to arms in support of their 'brothers' in Myanmar. The writer of the article seems to forget that Muslims don't need any excuse for launching a jihad against non-Muslims. Permanent violence against kafirs is enjoined upon all Muslims by their religion. But it is unlikely that Buddhist countries like Myanmar, Thailand and Sri Lanka, who still have some spunk left, will oblige the Muslims.
K T Thomas
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
All the conceded "kafirs" (you are calling yourself) are on the march,no matter what you wish or dream Islam is going to take its rightfull place on the world stage once again,these are just the initial signs of that imminent change.
observer
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
@Observer, there will be a repeat of 1947, in porkistan, nobody doubts that!
Obs
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
@Observer and we wont be the ones to do it....itll be ure great allies, cousins of those who orchestrated 1947... http://www.huffingtonpost.com/mobileweb/comments/2117534/fp/15/?icid=hp_world_art_comment_h
Obs
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
Happy Dewaali to all!
observer
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
Will the author tell us, what is happening to Bengali Hindus in Rakhine area. There are tens of thousands of Hindus live there .Usual Muslim activities are taking place against them,raping (Islamic tradition from the days of prophet) of women and killing of men and children.
Dipak
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
Dipak ,call hanuman for help (A Hindu tradition since the days of Shiva).
observer
November 13, 2012
Report Abuse
Considering Ramtanu Maitra sounds like a bengali name, this author seems to have forgotten the terror unleashed by muslims in Bengal during direct action day. There is no need to support rohingy muslims...they are reaping what they sowed in 1947. You got a country now do something to prosper in that country instead of becoming illegal immigrants in the neighboring countries and cause trouble to them.
asha
November 17, 2012
Report Abuse
@observer
Please get your facts correct before you comment.Hanuman came longtime after Siva.Read the article "Vedic Arabia" by Qureshi Khan.This will give an idea of Hindu influence in Arabland before Md.'s arrival.You will find Arabs worshipping Hindu gods at thet time. One of the Hidu god has half-moon (crescent) on his forehead. If you are a Muslim ,do a bit of study and find out who were your ancestors and how they were converted..
Why can't we live peacefully together, ofcourse Islam won't allow it.
dipak
November 17, 2012
Report Abuse
Keep going to Hindunity type sites,this what you gonna get,quiet obvious!
observer
November 18, 2012
Report Abuse