Challenge called Bihar: Ram Rajya in Sita’s homeland
by Rohit Srivastava on 26 Nov 2010 20 Comments

The historic victory of NDA in the recent state election has changed the political landscape dramatically. The liberal media was adamant about its preconceived notion that the widely expected NDA victory would rest solely on the charisma of Chief Minister Nitish Kumar; indeed the conventional wisdom in these circles was that the Bharatiya Janata Party would drag down the alliance by keeping the Muslim Vote at bay. Possibly even Nitish Kumar was influenced by this propaganda, and this may have played a role in the final division of seats between the allies.

 

In the event, the result proved a game changer in many ways. It showed that the coalition won as a united entity, and that proven performance plus future promise gave the regime another mandate. It proved that Media-driven personal charm (read Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi) is no substitute for grassroots work, proper planning, and door-to-door campaigning by dedicated, committed and responsible cadres.

 

That is how the BJP finally won 89% (91) of the seats it contested, and Janata Dal (United) 77% (115) of the seats it contested. Both parties won their respective seats on real hard work done, and perceived to have been done in the respective constituencies, by the people of Bihar; there is no question of piggy-back; both pulled their own weight. Even better, both party workers in the respective constituencies seem to have worked without bias for each others’ candidates. This performance – as opposed to the old discredited management of booths and voters and fear psychosis – brought in the votes.

 

The greatest upset was the fact that Muslims broke out of the ghettos created by Nehruvian Stalinists and voted for the alliance, that is, they voted for both the JD-U and the BJP candidates, and contributed to the landslide victory in no small measure. Bihar, land of Sri Mahavir ji, had its most non-violent election ever, and minorities and tribals in the Naxal-ridden belt, all voted without fear. It was participatory democracy at its best – Ram Rajya – with the promise of peace, progress and prosperity for all, without distinction of caste or religion or gender or region, you name it, and that is the ultimate Hindu civilisational quest.

 

Of course, the pseudo-secularists are having a hard time digesting the victory of the BJP. Former chief minister Lalu Yadav gracelessly said he would not congratulate the BJP; Ram Vilas Paswan was even more ungracious; and while Ms Sonia Gandhi remembered to congratulate the victorious chief minister, she was too agitated to remember to add ‘ji’ to his name, which is not a small faux pas in public life. Naturally, she omitted mention of the BJP altogether. Possibly she was upset at the scale of the BJP’s recent victory in the Gujarat local elections; Bihar coming so soon after – that too after Congress was literally decimated by the Rahul Factor – would naturally upset her. After all, even the biased media is privately assessing how long the days of the Dynasty will last.

 

Throughout the lengthy election campaign, the national media gave the public no hint about what the results could be like (though one TV channel made an amazingly accurate poll survey at the end of the elections). Most journalists simply failed to realise that in a vibrant and thriving democracy it’s the intricacies of local political fights and the personal view of every individual voter that counts. The political churning that goes on in villages and city streets can’t be understood by talking to ignorant and elitist intellectuals. They were caught napping when Total Revolution II happened!

 

But much more now needs to be done.

 

Bihar is a challenge, to nation, history, its people and the rest. Why? Bihar is a product of its own ignorance and others’ apathy. Bihar has been exporting its workforce for the last one and a half century. The current generation is earning wealth for other states. Why is a workforce so well received in other places not interested in working at home? No Bihari hates his state or forgets it. Our relation with our roots is strong and thriving.

 

Historic circumstances have never allowed Bihar to create opportunities for its own workforce. The most backward places in India at the time of independence were those ruled directly by the British – so much for the White Man’s Burden! Bihar, Bengal, UP, are prime examples of this. Then, the most underdeveloped regions of India, spread across the central plateau and the Gangetic plains, should have been the richest for the simple reason that they have all the desired resources and the history of India proves it. Why did the British chose to rule these areas directly? For money. Post-independence also, the flight of wealth continued with only a shift of destination of the wealth, from London to Delhi.

 

Resource-rich Jharkhand, once part of Bihar, couldn’t generate wealth for Bihar thanks to centralized planning and nationalization of resources. The PSUs earned for the nation but paid taxes to Bengal and Mumbai as their headquarters were situated there. Will the Government of India pay this money back to Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh and Orissa?

 

Bihar is no exception. To have a resurgent Bihar, we need to analyze the factors that have made other states so successful. Thus, the south Indian states have developed due to the sea coast. All the small and medium scale industry which came up during 1970s and 1980s has benefitted from that.

 

FDI comes only to developed places, not underdeveloped ones. The educationally backward areas of Gurgaon grew into a knowledge economy because it was near Delhi, but Patna which has far more educated youth did not rise. Business and investment comes where there is infrastructure; every one wants a quick buck.

 

Bangalore benefitted from the Indian Institute of Science, which became the keel of the industrial and scientific hub it has now become. In this regard, Central support to Bihar has been exceptionally poor. Yet Bihar sends its students to study across the country, so entrenched is the desire for education. Yet the Central Government has not bothered to start universities or invest in education in the state. Why should research and development funds go to universities with better resources? Isn’t it another vicious cycle where UGC funds universities with better infrastructure and resources, instead of developing new centres of excellence all over the country?

 

Any neutral observer would see the truth of these observations. Yet the elitist media finds it easy to tag Bihar and the common Bihari as the epitome of everything negative. For the media, political change in Bihar is a miracle; any new beginning is seen as a radical step in a society which is dead or dying. It is media which labelled Bihar a casteist society. But which state in India is not? More fundamentally, caste is not ‘bad’ thing at all, any more than religion is. Caste is simply one’s basic individual, family, clan identity; one’s lineage and civilisational heritage. Since when has Identity become a bad word? A person without an identity is eternally a problem for himself and society.

 

Every society in the world, in every era, has politics revolving around identity. And identity has never been a hindrance in development. This can be seen in developed parts of India even today. What the Media and Secular Intellectuals cannot digest is that the Bihar election has proved that Caste has not lost its relevance in politics but that it has started behaving differently. Caste is not a hindrance in the development agenda – there is no issue of Caste OR Development, Religion OR Development. People voted for good governance and the promise of a better future across lines of caste and religion; they refused to be cowed down by so-called community leaders and tied to a caste or religious identity post. They voted for their aspirations as a people, with caste, with religion, and not despite caste or to spite religion!

 

Professional secularists were left speechless. For the past year they were chattering about a possible rift between the BJP and JD-U and how BJP’s Hindutva is an issue. But people rebuffed them well. Like cracked gramophone records, they are now predicting a split on the grounds of Hindutva! A leopard cannot easily change its spots.

 

Can anyone suggest a better model of society than Ram Rajya or the post-Vedic society in terms of liberal thoughts and minds? Today’s knowledge economy can’t survive without liberal thinking where one can disagree and yet be teacher and pupil like in the Vedic times. The idea might seem far-fetched, but the most fast developing states today are BJP-ruled, while Communist-ruled Bengal reeks of poverty and Congress rule across India needs no comment. Only the Delhi based intelligentsia seems unable to come to terms with the changing world.

 

The keynote of this election, for me, is the beginning of the assertiveness of the downtrodden, which will bring this elitist lobby down its high horse. The complete shattering of the aura carefully erected around Rahul Gandhi in the in Bihar election is just a hint of things to come…

 

The writer is a journalist who hails from Bihar

User Comments Post a Comment
Dear all truthseekers,
Shri Rohit Srivastav has summed up the Bihari situation so well .
Let us hope that the environment in Bihar changes from that of the ASUR raj of Lalloo and ilk, to that of Ramraj and Saraswatiraj and Laxmi raj - as exemplefied by the universites of Nalanda and Taxila, and the rich resources and potential of its hardwoking people.
tarish kaushik
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
Well-written column. BJP has indeed asserted itself in Bihar. Nitish would have certainly realised the strength of BJP. He would not risk to do a Naveen Patnaik here. The ugly Congress, with the help of conniving media, will try to pull Nitish away from BJP. BJP would do better by maintaining and improving its contact with the masses.
B.R.Haran
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
In its' quest for political domination, the Kkangress has repeatedly backed all the wrong people, aided by the corrupt ELM: Laloo , Paswan, Karunanidhi, Mulayam and Mayawati (the last being reluctant allies).All of the above are basically predictable,negative entities It is hard to believe that Nitish Kumar and Laloo were "followers" of the same JP. It appears that Nitish is capable of achieving results both as a Railway Minister and then the CM.
Finally, decades of Kkangress mis-governance, followed by 15 years of Laloo mis-governance has a positive end.
seadog4227
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
The point of taxes paid from profits earned due to activities in these Bihar Jharkhand states being credited to Mumbai/ Bengal states is a very strong point and has a solution even now, as the problem persists. Solution is in modifying the accounting practices. just as accounts and balance sheets show category wise production figures, they should also show plant wise production value and attributed profits . then profits can be apportioned to state wise based on plant location. this proportion should be carried over to the advance tax payment forms . Then when center distributes the states share of direct taxes each state would get its share based on the profitability of production units in their state. This appears complicated but can be refined and implemented.
ravi
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
TO say the victory of NDA in Bihar is the victory of devlopment is nothig but a great lie,in fact it was the victory of social manipulation.The day Nitish came to power in Bihar he started cultivating new social alliance. In this process he gave reservation to Most backward castes in Panchayat and muncipalitis.Further he divided SCs into two groups dalits and mahadalits leaving out only one caste i.e Dusadhs of which his political rival Ram bilas paswan belongs to. Both of these steps go against the spirit our constituion.Later step is also unethical.NDA govt. in Bihar also proved greatest minority appeaser in the history of Bihar.When I pointed out this to local BJP leaders they said they were doing this to win muslim's support though they conceded that Muslim would not vote for them but they would not tacticly vote against them.Before just concluded election upper castes were angry with Nitish kumar but fearing Laloo,s come back they ranged behind him and voted solidly in favour of NDA.Someone rightly said"hanth mein vikas ka Jhanda lekar hum logo ne jati ke nam par vote is bar diya hai(In this election we have voted for caste while holding devlopmet's flag in our hands).
Rakesh
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
thanks for the comments
Rohit
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
the media is a congress slave .this was evident from 1976 indira's emergency,it never rose,except perhaps mr goenka;s they ahve developed a vested interest and so began manipulating the news to boost smallest achievement of the italian but withheld any achievement big or small of the bjp and others,tides have turned since 1992 and congress is fast losing ground with akk its slaes till paying obesance to the foreigner.the liht at the end of tunnel is seen and growing bigger the dawn is not far off.jai hind
karunganni
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
Congrats Rohit !
well done ..
I am always impressed with your intelligence and efforts for the search.
Wish You Success Ahead
Regards,
Shalini
Shalini
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
Nice article rohit

Keep on the good work
power to your pen
paromita
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
nice article
Dharmendra
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
deep thinking by the writer for bihar
sonu gill
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
good thoughts
sunny sardar
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
The congress party is a minimalist party as far as people are concerned. Maximizing at the same time the Nehruvian clan's 'glorious' grip on the national attention and hence crucial say on everything. Congress was and is never serious about people's true happiness. It ia prisoner of self inflicted and self-only serving idelogically dressed up lies.
gaurav
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
Rohit's point on identity hits right on the mark. His expose of the elitist english media is commendable. Above all his unselfish love for the people - of Bihar - in particular is the true ingredient with which silent revolutions are made.
govinda
November 26, 2010
Report Abuse
Friends, the euphoria at BJP's superlative showing in Bihar is contagious, indeed! We feel extremely privileged to share this with you. Let's look at this unprecented victory of more than 89% seats of the total number of seats contested being captured in an appreciative light. Can we look at measuring the vicory with other yardsticks than those established by the Congress rulers for more than 50 years? Let's look at startegies being adopted by Narendra Modiji and the developmental progress that he & his team have been able to accomplish within 10 years in spite of the continuing Congress digs at destabilising the BJP Govt. in Gujarat. Similarly, in Bihar. It may perhaps be a shade too early as the coalition team of Nitish Kumar, Sushil Modi & Co continue to fight the Congress & Lalu latthraj there and the tooth & nail response so effectively provided by them to their opponents destabilising efforts. Their development-centric & progressive focused approach, a la Narendraji, will now begin to take shape we hope. Moreover, Kumar Swamy, Deve Gowda, Congress & their gangsters in Karnataka have not permitted BSY & Team to perform to their capacities. They too need some basic time frame to ward off the ongoing & unproductive attacks on them.
Let's not permit the Ashok Gehlot kind of politics to take over the development-oriented efforts in Karnataka - I believe if the Central BJP leadership continues to allow the development of their vision in the South, and nurture the development of practical & progressive strategies there, as perhaps only this kind of approach at supporting BSY & team can prove to be more positive & result-oriented than any that the opposition Congress can even dream of! The Central BJP leadership has already engaged the Congress in the various scams - 2G scam, CWG scam, Adarsh scam ... Yes, the BJP's outstanding performance in Bihar needs to be applauded, savoured and nurtured to accomplish the standards set by Narendra Modi in Gujarat, and let them develop strategies and shields to combat the nefarious onslaughts from their Congress opponents who have been decimated to 4 seats in the State Legislature - this is BJP's best performance ever, this is also the 125-years old Congress' nadir to date! Wherever the credit is due, let's recognise it. Kudos to the entire BJP party cadres!
Piyush
November 27, 2010
Report Abuse
Nobody will say this but the trends are obvious. The Indian voter may not have abandoned caste-centric voting, but has cautiously endorsed in the last few elections the setting aside of caste for economic and security reasons. The trend started, me thinks, in Gujarat election 2007 and it followed ever since. Even the next general elections will be fought differently and the main beneficiary would be BJP simply because it appeals to 'economic interests' far better than social engineering. This means the vote would be seen as a consolidation of Hindu votes and analysts as is their wont, will comment on 'saffron' or 'Hindutva' vote. In a divide and conquer strategy BJP will not succeed since it has never been its strategy nor it appeals to it. BJP ideology has always been nationalistic : one nation, one people and one law. With the rise of BJP states and their economic success in delivering services and creating economic opportunities with little or no taint of corruption to their governance, BJP has a great advantage going into 2014 elections compared to Congress or the now again then again 3rd front. Hence 'economic progress' is Hindtuva. Hindutva encompasses a large and an almost enviable canvass. Core of its value comes from 'economic progress'. When a BJP state with and/ without partners wins elections, it is Hindutva which won, as has been the case since last 20+ years in one form or the other. Before long, watch for analysts pompously declare that 'secular' politics victory over 'communal' politics. Doing so they are appropriating the overwhelming success of 'development' politics largely practiced by BJP governments. This is nonsense. secularism and its sibling, socialism are resounding failures. BJP governments practice good governance. Good governance is Hindutva.
Ramana
November 27, 2010
Report Abuse
Rohit your views on political arena in Bihar and entire nation is very well versed. As you sum up, things have been projected very clearly. Good written article keep it up.
sweta
November 27, 2010
Report Abuse
The writer has projected the scenario on its actuality. Strong hold on political issues. The entire nation waited eagerly and was glued to their television sets since early morning to keep abreast of what was the final verdict. History repeats itself. Good going Rohit.
anamika
November 27, 2010
Report Abuse
Congrats for a well balanced article which took as back to Ramayana times. I never wondered about Rama' Ayodhya and Sita's Mithila location as being presently in UP and Bihar respy. I wondered about Pataliputra and the types of Lalu ruling over it for two long. I am also happy about the mention of Indian Institute of Science, with which I have five decades of association since 1961. Prosperity of UP and Bihar is essential for India's prosperity. We wish a new dawn for Bihar.
V V S Sarma
November 27, 2010
Report Abuse
Well done BJP in Bihar. Learnings on dealing with a strong coalition CM to be adapted in Punjab otherwise the Badals will take the BJP down with it. Also BJP should try to rebuild bridges with Odissa CM Patnaik, work at grassroot level so that in next state elections it does well in Odissa forcing CM to make them a coalition partner. Time lagega but worth it. In Maharashtra BJP is inactive, there is such a strong anti Congress wave post Adarsh but no state leader of repute who can take the battle into the enemy camp.
sanjeev nayyar
November 28, 2010
Report Abuse
Comments are free. However, comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate material will be removed from the site. Readers may report abuse at  editorvijayvaani@gmail.com
Post a Comment
Name
E-Mail
Comments