India under eclipse: the political folly – 2
by Nancy Kaul on 07 Jun 2010 11 Comments

For a Nation the people, the constitution, the armed forces and sovereignty along with territorial integrity are non-negotiable; the political leadership with its policies and decisions must abide by this. Each and every elected member of the Republic takes an oath to protect the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the nation.

 

The folly of the leadership and political set up in the country is leaving little in the way of those who are hammering at the very nationhood of India – its people, culture, historical and civilisational moorings, economic and geo-political strategic contours.

 

The long term strategy of Pakistan is to dismember India, while adding a thousand cuts through the terror network. In this strategy, unconventional warfare and Jihadi terrorism are tools of warfare.

 

Separatists add to this multi-dimensional war by terror. On November 1, 2001, Syed Ali Geelani, a separatist leader in the Valley, said, “'It is an unrealistic claim to say Jammu and Kashmir is an integral part of India.” Geelani’s remarks show that the sinister design has not been given up but only made deeper inroads.

 

It is therefore not surprising that separatists, secessionists and their Pakistani supporters go to the extent of comparing the ongoing terrorist and Jihadi violence in Kashmir to a freedom struggle. The spurt in Jihadi terrorism across the country for the last few years is to be perceived as part of Pakistan's ‘grand design’ against India.

 

Valley based politicians in different voices hammer at the nation State of India. Proposals of Self Rule, Autonomy, and Greater Autonomy all have their genesis in a US report. One of the proposals that Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee and Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf considered during the Agra Summit was opening of the Muzaffarabad-Srinagar road for another Indo-Pak bus service, leading to some kind of a free trade zone in the long run. The Pakistani President and Chief Executive Officer, Gen Pervez Musharraf clearly said he wanted concessions of these kind and more.

 

These demands of Autonomy, Self Rule and Greater Autonomy are part of a 1998 Kashmir Study Group Report, titled “Livingston Proposal: Kashmir, A Way Forward.” Also known as the Farooq Kathwari report, the document aims at diluting Indian sovereignty in the State of Jammu and Kashmir. The US political establishment had offered some insights into its vision of settling the Kashmir dispute through this report, which speaks of a degree of autonomy to the region.

 

The report contained ways and means of creating a sovereign entity of Kashmir. It first envisages creation of two Kashmir entities - one each on either side of the LoC, each with its own government, constitution and a working relationship with either India or Pakistan or both.

 

The second proposal talks of a single Kashmiri entity with its own constitutional framework and government. As per the report, the new entity will have its constitution as well as citizenship rights, flag and a legislature. Kashmiri citizenship may allow them to acquire entity passports, the report suggested, while giving six working formulas of the sovereign entity which differ only in detail. All formulae aim to further dilute the relations of the State with India and are on communal lines.

 

The report includes a memorandum, prepared by Hurst Hannum, professor of International Law at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, Tufts University, Medford, US. It is divided into three sections, dealing with issues of legislation, citizenship and currency, in its first part, followed by options of the Kashmiri entity, and the final section suggesting how an agreement on Kashmir can be given legal standing through an India-Pakistan treaty.

 

Where in the world does one find a sovereign entity within a sovereign country as is being propounded by the report? All the confidence-building measures that Pakistan wants India to take are actually aimed at further alienating Jammu and Kashmir from the country. The agenda of this report is to alienate Jammu and Kashmir from the Constitution of India.

 

This agenda got a flip when the Centre passed the Sager Ahmed committee recommendation envisaging autonomy for the State. It is not just going to define what and how autonomy of the State as perceived by National Conference, its Kashmiri Muslim-centric wants, and indifference to other regions and populations, but will also define how Indian leadership wants the world to see its sovereign and territorial frontiers - in terms of south and central Asia and the emerging world order.

 

Today, as the Prime Minister readies to go to Srinagar for another two day visit, Mirwaiz Umar Farooq wants a political package for Kashmir. He is actually batting for Pakistan and the Jihadi terrorists, “If you are saying that we have to wait for the last gun to fall silent, that’s not going to happen. Even the Jihad Council or the parties outside the council are maintaining the minimum number to attack installations of the Army or paramilitary forces.”

 

Mirwaiz of Hurriyat is joined by Mehbooba Mufti of PDP who now wants devolution of the Preamble and the Constitution, as her self rule propaganda envisages. Her wish-list wants semi-sovereign status for the State in future, “Jammu and Kashmir enjoys the status of a semi-sovereign state and gets unified with the other Kashmir (POK).”

 

State Chief Minister Omar Abdullah is a proponent of the honourable return of Kashmiri terrorists from Pakistan, whereas his government and the Sri Amarnath Shrine Board levied a Jazia-like tax on Amarnath yatra, raising startling questions.

 

The reins of power are fast corrupting the corridors of power. In a recent visit to Ramban and Doda, DGP Kuldeep Khuda called it a visit to Chenab Valley (March 3, 2010)! This is in conformity with the Greater Autonomy Committee report of the National Conference, which proposes to divide Jammu & Kashmir into eight regions along ethnic-religious lines –Kamraz, Nundabad, Maraz, Chenab Valley, Jammu, Pir Panjal, Kargil and Ladakh.

 

Though the DGP did not waste a moment to confer awards and recommendations with employment in JK police to Ruksana for fighting terrorists, he was found faltering in the case of the brave Sunita Kumari of Kalakote, who killed Hizbul Mujahedeen terrorists as they attacked her house, killing her father and injuring her along with her sister. Sunita is now hiding and trying to save her life from the HM terrorists as the State Government then led by Farooq Abdullah reneged on the promise of job with the state police department. Such aberrations of State policy do not auger well in terms of governance.

 

In the light of the above, if the Government passes recommendations on the Autonomy Committee report, greater autonomy, self rule, without giving thought to its long-term implications in terms of law, States and jurisdiction, it would term hurtle towards greater damage in terms of sovereignty, territorial integrity and the unity of the country.

 

Kashmir-centric politicians and their sympathizers with these demands and proposals are neither new nor different – but are with the agenda of devolution of Indian sovereignty, territorial integrity and constitution: with the aim of strengthening the stranglehold of separatist identity and creating a Muslim sphere of interest and the Balkanization of India.

 

The blanking out of other regions of the State in terms of development, governance, employment and political aspirations by Valley-centric politicians is intrinsic to this mindset.

 

Will the Prime Minister and the Government continue the dichotomy towards interests of strategic importance, governance, sovereignty and territorial integrity, for no nation survives on weak knees and spinelessness!!

 

- Before you start some work, always ask yourself three questions - Why am I doing it, What the results might be, and Will I be successful. As soon as the fear approaches near, attack and destroy it. An enemy should be destroyed without a trace" - Chanakya

 

(Concluded)

The author is convener, Daughters of Vitasta

User Comments Post a Comment
I have read with interest the write up ‘India under eclipse: the political folly’ by Nancy Kaul. Many of the concerns as raised by the author need attention. However, the plight of nearly half a million exiled Kashmiri Pandits sadly has no mention. One fails to understand how a nation of 1250 million strong head count can act in a meek manner and that always puts Kashmir in focus as if Jammu and Ladhak, the other two important regions of the state do not exist. Proposals like Autonomy or Self-Rule have hardly any takers in these regions. In solving the ‘Kashmir’ issue, it remains absolutely essential to take into consideration the urges and aspirations of all sections /regions of the state. Unfortunately the exiled community of Kashmiri Pandits, an ethnic minority of the state and currently in 21st year of forced exile, continues to be the concern of none. That is why meeting these ‘Internally Displaced’ people or visiting them in the camps is not on the itinerary of the present visit of the Prime Minister to the Valley. Most of the real issues continue to be ‘under eclipse’. Shame ! ………..RAMESH MANVATI
RAMESH MANVATI
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
it is important for all us Indians to understand the ramifications of what is happening in jammu and kashmir. these are truly as the writer said dangerous signs for our country, people, our civilisation and heritage. jazia for hindus and honourable return for terrorists.
Mr Prime Minister will you sell India for Muslim Goushtaba?
AK Singh, Jammu
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
India under eclipse- is truly an insight on the dangerous game of balkanizing India and talibanizing ! are indians on opium that we do not understand this. These are not concerns but reality of India trying to kill its ownself.
Astonishing to read what the DG police has done - seems like he is also furthering the agenda of the separatists!
kamakshi S
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
these are not concerns but Islamic agenda. ramesh manvati kashmiri Pandits are responsible for this state of affairs. Nehru was a Kashmir Pandit, the present DG Police Kuldeep Khuda is a kashmiri pandit, whose police opened fire on Jammuities who were peacefullly demonstrating against the kashmiri muslim hegemony with regard to Shri Amarnath Yatra, should you not be ashamed of him.
If he calls ramban areas as Chenab Valley is he not a stooge of the national Conference who want greater autonomy to divide India and further away State from the Indian nation.
Why has he done nothing for Sunita: is it not because she is a Hindu girl as he went on and on about Ruksana.
What about the Amitabh mattoo- has kashmiri Pandit community disowned him for writing the self rule document for PDP. As the VC he Islamised even jammu University - he is a muslim dhimmi.
What did the ex chief secretary of jammu and Kashmir, an kashmiri pandit do???
Kashmiri Pandits still lick the kashmiri muslims even thiugh Hindus have stood by them. It was these kashmiri pandits who furthered the separatists agenda of son of the soil????
Did Nandita Haksar not fight for terrorists who have time and again hammered at India.
Are kashmiri pandits not enjoying benefits all across the country in terms of financial help and educational seats, where displaced Hindus are still an ignored lot.
shame on these people; india needs to be saved - first and formost.
AK Singh, Jammu
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
excellent eye opener with regard to the deeper dangers. Why is our political leadership in such a defunct state of affairs?
Umesh Mathur
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
@ Ramesh Manvati - it is a yuga since a Kashmiri Hindu has commented on ANY article on this website, and that too only to make the puerile comments like this //the plight of nearly half a million exiled Kashmiri Pandits sadly has no mention// Where are you man? One fails to understand how Kashmiri Pandits who themselves pussyfoot with all manner of people for small gains, don't stand up and be counted on any issue of national importance, and resent when a Nationalist Kashmiri Hindu Woman speaks for all India and Jammu and Ladakh, WHY only their small thinkign should prevail? In 21 years of exile, how many Kashmiri Pandits have joined the police and armed forces and prepared for national qurbani? They are just getting fat and lazy on free ration cards, and now everyone knows it. It was RICH Kashmiri Pandits who paid for an Exodus Day function in Delhi in January, and invited Madhu Kishwar to defend the Autonomy case. What more needs to be said about this bunch, eh?
Padma
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
Khoda is an opportunist. he will do anything for his bosses.
Yamini
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
The truths are here in front of us. These issues of autonomy, greater autonomy, self rule etc - are different shades of devolution of Indian sovereignity and territory. The Americans have always supported diversionary tactics there it is small surprise that all these separatist ideas come from there think tank.
It is Indias business to stand on its knees and back bone. Will the Prime Minister or will he add to the withering away of our nation through the political follies just as the Writer pointed out! Vijvaani has done its job well will the political establishment too????
K kulkarni
June 07, 2010
Report Abuse
The sinister ploy of Congress to split and sell the country to islamists for the sake of vote bank politics is further evidenced with clarity in this narrative. When will the country awake to realize its gross errors by voting a party with sinister intentions at the helm of power remains to be seen. However, the efforts of Vijvaani and its eminent writers are worthy to the few readers like us who can take it up further, share it with the few we know, and force them to introspect for the sake of India.
Prashanth K.P.
June 08, 2010
Report Abuse
My comments about the write-up ‘India under eclipse: the political folly’ by Nancy Kaul seem to be misunderstood by some hon'ble readers. The concerns raised by me only substantiate most of the issues raised by Nancy Kaul (a well known firebrand activist) in her present write-up. The fact of the matter is that because of the weak-need policies, including appeasing Muslim 'minority' (otherwise a majority in J&K State), pursued by both the State and Central Governments over the years, are responsible for the mess that we find the State in at the present. The forced exodus of nearly half a million Kashmiri Pandits, in 1989/’90, is surely a blot on secular India and so-called ‘Kashmiriat’. Being myself a victim of terrorism and having lived a life of a refugee in my own country away from my ancestral roots , one only prays to save others from facing such horrific situations .
I must reiterate - ‘ One fails to understand how a nation of 1250 million strong head count can act in a meek manner and that always puts Kashmir in focus as if Jammu and Ladhak, the other two important regions of the state do not exist. Proposals like Autonomy or Self-Rule have hardly any takers in these regions. In solving the ‘Kashmir’ issue, it remains absolutely essential to take into consideration the urges and aspirations of all sections /regions of the state’.
UPA Govt.’s agenda of track-two diplomacy needs to be watched carefully and no compromise on the sovereignty and integrity of the nation can be tolerated by the people as rightly pointed out by the author…..…Orzuv !
RAMESH MANVATI
June 08, 2010
Report Abuse
The issues raised by Ms Nancy Kaul are dangers which have truly eclipsed India. The questions cannot be shoved under the carpet. What is autonomy and self rule and as the writer has brought out it is truly a plan to divide India.
The american intiative on this is nothing new and the often remarks of kashmir issue and solution is not to be viewed through their agenda.
the solution of jammu and Kashmir lies in a strong leader and a stronger nation, 1994 resolution of the parliament of India has made it clear. all that need to be resolved is the pakistan occupied Jammu and Kashmir and the areas that they have further given to China. No amount of any tracks except for this will be acknowledged by the people of India. the Prime MInister and the Home Minister should stand on their feet not kneel on their knees to guide and lead the Nation!
shivika gadgil patil
June 12, 2010
Report Abuse
Comments are free. However, comments that include profanity or personal attacks or other inappropriate material will be removed from the site. Readers may report abuse at  editorvijayvaani@gmail.com
Post a Comment
Name
E-Mail
Comments